Puffy vs Casper Mattress Canada: Comprehensive Comparison Guide

When you're shopping for a new mattress in Canada, you'll likely come across two popular brands that have made significant waves in the sleep industry: Puffy and Casper. As mattress experts at Fawcett Mattress, we understand the importance of finding the perfect sleep surface that meets your unique needs. Both Puffy vs Casper offer well-designed foam mattresses, but how do they really compare? And could a natural latex or hybrid mattress be an even better option for you?

In this comprehensive guide, we'll break down everything you need to know about Puffy vs Casper mattresses, helping you make an informed decision about which might better suit your sleeping position, body type, and comfort preferences.

Puffy vs Casper: At-a-Glance Comparison

Puffy and Casper Mattress Comparison Breakdown

Both Puffy and Casper have built strong reputations in the mattress industry, with multiple models designed to cater to different sleeper types. Let's examine how they stack up against each other across several important factors.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Puffy Mattress Construction:
Puffy offers several models, including the Puffy Cloud, Puffy Lux Hybrid, and Puffy Royal Hybrid. The standard Puffy Cloud mattress features a three-layer construction with:

• A cooling gel-infused comfort layer that helps dissipate heat
• A responsive transition layer to prevent excessive sinking
• A supportive base foam for durability and structure

The Puffy Lux adds an additional comfort layer and replaces the base foam with pocketed coils for enhanced support and airflow.

Casper Mattress Construction:
Casper's lineup includes the Casper Original mattress (available in all-foam or hybrid versions), the plush Nova Hybrid, and the supportive Casper Wave Hybrid. The Casper Original features:

• A perforated AirScape foam comfort layer for cooling
• A zoned support memory foam layer with three ergonomic zones
• A durable high-density polyfoam base

What sets Casper apart is their zoned support technology, which provides targeted relief by being softer under shoulders and firmer under hips and lower back to keep your spine neutrally aligned.

Both brands use CertiPUR-US certified foams, meaning they're made without harmful chemicals and have low VOC emissions. However, if you're looking for truly natural materials, our handcrafted latex mattresses offer a more eco-friendly alternative made right here in Canada.

Comfort Layers and Support

Puffy Comfort System:
Puffy's comfort layers use their proprietary "Cooling Cloud foam," which is infused with cooling gel to help regulate temperature for hot sleepers. The Puffy Lux adds a "Dual Cloud" layer for additional pressure relief, particularly beneficial for side sleepers.

The support systems vary by model:

• The Puffy Cloud uses a 6" high-density support core
• The Lux and Royal Hybrids use individually wrapped coils (approximately 6-7" tall with counts ranging from 850-1,000+ in queen size)

Casper Comfort System:
Casper's comfort approach centers around their AirScape foam, which features small perforations to increase airflow. Their zoned support layer is particularly innovative, featuring three zones of varying firmness to align the spine while providing pressure relief.

Casper's support cores include:

• A 7.5" high-density polyfoam base in the all-foam models
• A 6" pocketed coil system in their hybrid versions

While both brands offer quality materials, we've found many of our customers prefer the natural resilience and breathability of our best hybrid mattresses, which combine pocketed coils with natural latex for superior comfort.

Edge Support and Motion Transfer

Edge Support:
Edge support determines how well a mattress performs when you sit or sleep near its perimeter. This is particularly important for couples sharing a smaller bed or those who use the entire surface area.

Puffy's edge support varies by model:

• The Puffy Cloud shows deeper sinkage (around 4.5") when sitting on the edge
• The Lux Hybrid offers improved edge support thanks to its coil system, but still exhibits some compression

Casper generally outperforms Puffy in edge support:

• The Casper Select shows excellent edge support with only 3.75" of sinkage
• Even the all-foam Casper Original maintains decent perimeter support
• The hybrid models feature reinforced edges for enhanced stability

Motion Transfer:
For couples, motion isolation can be the difference between a restful night and being disturbed by a partner's movements.

Puffy excels in motion isolation:

• The Cloud absorbs up to 90% of movement
• Even the hybrid models perform well, though some motion can transfer through the coil systems

Casper also performs admirably:

• The all-foam mattresses provide exceptional motion isolation
• The hybrid versions allow slightly more motion transfer but still minimize disruptions

For couples seeking both strong edge support and excellent motion isolation, our handcrafted hybrid mattresses offer the perfect balance, with pocketed coils that work independently to prevent motion transfer while maintaining supportive edges.

Height and Weight

Mattress Profiles:
The height of a mattress affects not only how it feels but also practical concerns like sheet fitting and ease of getting in and out of bed.

Puffy mattress heights:

• Puffy Cloud: 10"
• Puffy Lux: 12"
• Puffy Royal Hybrid: 14"

Casper mattress heights:

• Casper Original: 11"
• Casper Nova Hybrid: 12"
• Casper Wave Hybrid: 13"

Weight Capacity:
Weight capacity is crucial for durability and proper support, especially for heavier individuals or couples.

While both brands claim to support a wide range of body types, our testing and customer feedback suggest:

• Puffy mattresses generally support up to 350 pounds per person (700 pounds total)
• Casper hybrid models can support up to 400 pounds per person
• Both brands' all-foam beds may show premature wear with sleepers over 230 pounds

For heavier individuals, we often recommend our premium hybrid mattresses with reinforced support systems designed specifically for higher weight capacities.

Durability

Durability determines how well your mattress maintains its support and comfort over time.

Puffy Durability:

• All-foam models are projected to last 7-10 years with proper care
• Hybrid models may extend this to 8-12 years
• Puffy offers a lifetime warranty, suggesting confidence in their product longevity

Casper Durability:

• All-foam models typically last around 7 years
• Hybrid versions can extend to 10 years
• Casper provides a 10-year warranty

While both brands use quality materials, the truth is that synthetic foams typically break down faster than natural materials like latex. Our handcrafted mattresses use premium natural latex and high-quality coil systems, often providing 15+ years of consistent support and comfort.

Best Foam Mattresses for Lightweight Sleepers

Lightweight sleepers (under 130 pounds) have specific needs when it comes to mattress selection. Without enough body weight to engage with firmer materials, they need surfaces that offer immediate contouring and pressure relief.

For Lightweight Side Sleepers:
Puffy's Lux Hybrid offers excellent pressure relief for lightweight side sleepers. The softer comfort layers (rated around 6/10 for firmness) allow for shoulder and hip sinking without creating alignment issues. Casper's Nova Hybrid, their plushest option at 4.5/10 firmness, also provides exceptional contouring for side sleepers with lighter frames.

For Lightweight Back Sleepers:
The Casper Original (6.5/10 firmness) provides an excellent balance of support and comfort for lightweight back sleepers. Its zoned support system helps maintain proper spinal alignment even without significant body weight pressing into the mattress. The Puffy Cloud (7/10 firmness) also offers enough support for lightweight back sleepers while still providing adequate comfort.

Both Puffy and Casper foam mattresses benefit lightweight sleepers through:

• Immediate pressure response without requiring significant weight
• Balanced foam feel that prevents the "floating" sensation often experienced on firmer mattresses
• Adequate comfort layer depth to cushion bony prominences

However, for the ultimate in pressure relief for lightweight sleepers, consider our natural latex mattresses that respond instantly to even minimal pressure while providing consistent support throughout the night.

Foam Mattress Recommendations for Heavyweight Sleepers

Heavyweight sleepers (over 230 pounds) face different challenges. They need mattresses that prevent excessive sinking while still providing comfort and relieving pressure points.

For Heavyweight Side Sleepers:
Neither brand's all-foam models are ideal for heavyweight side sleepers, as they may sink too deeply, creating alignment issues. However, both brands' hybrid options offer improvements:

• Casper Wave Hybrid provides zoned support that prevents excessive hip sinking
• Puffy Royal Hybrid's 7" coil system offers better resilience for heavier bodies

For Heavyweight Back and Stomach Sleepers:
Heavyweight back sleepers and heavyweight stomach sleepers need significant support to maintain spinal alignment:

• The Casper Original Hybrid offers better support than its all-foam counterpart
• Puffy's Royal Hybrid with its zoned coil support can accommodate heavier weights

However, the truth is that most boxed foam mattresses aren't engineered specifically for heavyweight sleepers. Our handcrafted hybrid mattresses are designed with reinforced support zones and premium materials that can properly support heavier body types for years without excessive compression or sagging.

Benefits of a Foam Mattress for Better Sleep?

Foam mattresses have gained popularity for several compelling reasons:

Pressure Relief:
Both Puffy and Casper excel at distributing body weight and alleviating pressure points, particularly beneficial for side sleepers and those with joint pain. The memory foam layer contours to your body to relieve pressure where you need it most.

Motion Isolation:
Memory foam's ability to absorb movement rather than transfer it makes these mattresses excellent choices for couples or light sleepers easily disturbed by movement.

Affordability:
While premium options exist, foam mattresses generally offer good value, with both Puffy and Casper providing quality construction at reasonable price points.

Noise Reduction:
Unlike traditional spring mattresses, foam beds operate silently, creating a more peaceful sleep environment.

Adaptability:
Modern foam formulations adjust to your body weight and preferred sleeping position, providing personalized comfort without the need for flipping or rotating.

While both Puffy and Casper deliver these benefits, our experience has shown that combining the pressure relief of natural latex with the supportive benefits of individually wrapped coils creates the perfect sleep surface for most sleepers. That's why we've carefully designed our handcrafted hybrid mattresses to offer the best features of multiple layers and materials.

For more comparisons, explore how Purple stacks up against GhostBed, the Douglas vs Casper breakdown, or our take on the Purple vs Tempur-Pedic debate.

FAQs

How long will the Casper and Puffy mattresses last?

With proper care, Puffy mattresses typically last 7-10 years for all-foam models and 8-12 years for hybrids. Casper mattresses generally last 7 years for all-foam models and up to 10 years for hybrids. Both the Casper and Puffy offer warranties reflecting these expectations, with Puffy providing a lifetime warranty and Casper offering a 10-year limited warranty.

Factors affecting durability include:

• Your body weight and sleeping position
• Mattress rotation frequency
• Use of proper foundation or platform
• Humidity and temperature of your bedroom

For maximum longevity, we recommend using a quality mattress protector and rotating your mattress every 6 months.

Which mattress is better for side sleepers, Casper or Puffy?

For side sleepers, pressure relief at the shoulders and hips is critical. Both brands offer good options, but your specific needs may point you toward one over the other:

• Average weight side sleepers typically prefer the Puffy Lux Hybrid for its softer feel and deeper pressure relief
• Lightweight side sleepers often find the Casper Nova Hybrid ideal for its plush comfort layers
• Heavyweight side sleepers might be better served by the Casper Wave Hybrid with its enhanced zoned support

At Fawcett Mattress, we've designed our latex mattresses to provide outstanding pressure relief for side and back sleepers of all weights, with natural materials that contour to your body's unique curves.

What are the negatives of a puffy mattress?

While Puffy mattresses have many advantages, some potential drawbacks include:

• Edge support in the all-foam models is below average, which can be problematic for those who sit on the edge or sleep near the perimeter
• Some hot sleepers find the cooling features less effective than advertised, particularly in warmer climates
• Heavyweight sleepers (over 230 pounds) may find most models lack sufficient support for proper spinal alignment
• The softer models may not provide adequate support for strict stomach sleepers

No mattress is perfect for everyone, which is why we offer personalized consultations to help you find the ideal sleep solution for your unique needs.

How do the firmness scales compare between Puffy vs Casper mattresses?

When comparing the firmness scale ratings of both brands:

• The original Puffy Cloud offers a medium-firm feel at 7/10 on the firmness scale, making it suitable for back sleepers and those who prefer a firmer mattress
• Puffy Lux provides a medium firmness (6/10), ideal for side and combination sleepers who need pressure relief
• The Casper Original mattress falls around 6.5/10, offering a balanced foam feel that works for most sleepers
• Casper Nova offers a softer medium firmness (4.5/10), perfect for strict side sleepers and those with pressure points
• The Casper Wave Hybrid provides medium firmness (5/10) with enhanced support for heavier individuals

Remember that firmness is subjective based on your body weight and preferred sleeping position. What feels comfortable to one person might be too firm or too soft for another.

How do the foam layers in Puffy and Casper mattresses compare?

The foam layers in these mattresses differ significantly in construction and performance:

Puffy's Foam Layers:

• Top layer: Puffy uses gel-infused foam in their Cloud model's comfort layer, which helps maintain a comfortable temperature
• The Cloud foam technology provides a slower-responding memory foam feel that cradles the body
• Multiple layers of varying density foams work together to provide both contouring and support
• All-foam mattresses from Puffy have at least three distinct foam layers, while hybrids add a coil support system

Casper's Foam Layers:

• Top layer: Casper's perforated foam design (AirScape) allows for improved airflow, helping hot sleepers stay cooler
• Their memory foam layer is positioned as the second layer, beneath the AirScape foam, creating a balanced foam feel that prevents excessive sinking
• The zoned support foam in Casper mattresses is engineered with multiple zones of varying firmness to support different parts of the body
• Casper's original mattress is an all-foam bed with three distinct layers designed to work in harmony

Both companies use CertiPUR-US certified foams, but their approaches to comfort and support differ significantly. Puffy focuses more on a traditional memory foam mattress feel, while Casper aims for a more responsive, breathable design with their perforated foam technology.

In Conclusion

Both Puffy and Casper offer quality foam mattresses with distinct advantages. Puffy excels in pressure relief and motion isolation, with their lifetime warranty providing additional peace of mind. Casper stands out with their innovative zoned support technology and generally superior edge support.

For lightweight sleepers, either brand can provide excellent comfort, though Casper's zoned approach may offer better spinal alignment. Heavyweight sleepers should consider the hybrid options from either brand, though specialized mattresses may better serve their needs.

When choosing between Puffy vs Casper, consider your primary sleep position, body type, temperature preferences, and whether you share your bed. However, don't overlook the benefits that natural materials and handcrafted construction can provide. Our latex mattresses and hybrid mattresses combine the best features of multiple mattress types, delivering superior comfort, support, and durability.

Ready to find your perfect new mattress? Explore our collections or contact us to speak with a mattress expert who can guide you toward your best night's sleep.