Casper Mattress vs Leesa Mattress in Canada: Which Is Right for You in 2025?

When you're searching for a new mattress in Canada, you'll likely encounter two popular boxed mattress brands: Casper and Leesa. Both have built strong reputations in the direct-to-consumer space, but how do they truly compare? At Fawcett Mattress, we believe your mattress choice directly impacts your quality of life. That's why we're breaking down this Casper mattress vs Leesa mattress comparison—to help you navigate your options while highlighting natural alternatives that might better serve your sleep needs.

Mattress Comparison Table: Casper vs Leesa

Leesa and Casper: What Makes Them Different?

While both Casper and Leesa might appear similar at first glance, their approaches to comfort differ significantly. The Casper mattress focuses on zoned support—designing their mattresses with firmer foam in the hip area and softer foam around the shoulders. This creates targeted pressure relief that back sleepers often appreciate. The Leesa mattress, meanwhile, emphasizes uniform comfort with their proprietary Avena foam, which provides a more consistent feel throughout the mattress that many side sleepers prefer.

At Fawcett, we're particularly interested in how both companies approach Canadian needs. Our crafted latex mattresses take a different path altogether—using natural materials that adapt to your body without the synthetic ingredients found in conventional foam mattresses.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Casper Construction

The Casper mattress flagship model (also called The Casper) features three foam layers:

• A top layer of perforated polyfoam for cooling
• A middle layer of zoned memory foam for support
• A high-density polyfoam base layer

Their hybrid models add pocketed coils to the support core, enhancing responsiveness and airflow. All foams are CertiPUR-US certified, ensuring they're made without ozone-depleting chemicals and have low VOC emissions.

Leesa Construction

The Leesa mattress Original uses:

• A top layer of responsive Avena foam (a latex alternative)
• A middle layer of memory foam for pressure relief
• A base layer of high-density support foam

Their hybrid models replace the base foam with pocketed coils, improving durability and support. Like Casper, all foams are CertiPUR-US certified.

The Natural Alternative

At Fawcett, we take a fundamentally different approach with our hybrid mattresses. Rather than synthetic foams, we use natural latex harvested from rubber trees, organic cotton covers, and Joma wool quilted in cotton cover. This creates a sleep surface that's more responsive, longer-lasting, and free from the chemicals found in conventional foam mattresses.

Firmness and Feel

The Casper mattress typically rates medium to medium-firm (6-7/10), with their zoned design creating variable firmness throughout the mattress. Their slightly firmer feel makes them generally better for back sleepers and stomach sleepers.

Leesa mattresses trend softer at medium (5-6/10), with deeper contouring that side sleepers often prefer. The Avena foam creates a latex-like responsiveness while still allowing significant pressure relief.

What we've found at Fawcett is that no single firmness works for everyone. That's why we offer customizable firmness options, allowing you to select the perfect feel for your body type and sleeping position.

Edge Support and Motion Transfer

Edge Support

Edge support varies dramatically between models. Casper's all-foam mattresses show significant sinkage when sitting on the edge, with approximately 4.25 inches of compression. Their hybrid models perform better but still lag behind more traditional innerspring designs.

Leesa's hybrid models demonstrate superior edge integrity, especially the Legend Hybrid with its reinforced steel coils along the perimeter. However, their all-foam Original suffers from the same lack of edge support as most foam mattresses.

At Fawcett, we reinforce all our mattress edges with a double row of firmer coils, creating a supportive perimeter that doesn't collapse under weight—something particularly important for couples sharing a bed.

Motion Transfer

Both brands excel at motion isolation. Casper's all-foam models absorb nearly all movement, making them excellent for light sleepers with restless partners. Leesa performs similarly well, with the Original model ranking among the best for motion isolation.

Our crafted mattresses combine individually wrapped coils with latex comfort layers, creating exceptional motion isolation while maintaining the responsiveness that's lacking in all-foam designs.

Body Weight and Mattress Height

Heavier sleepers (over 230 lbs) may find both Casper and Leesa all-foam models insufficient for long-term support. The hybrid versions perform better but still may not provide adequate durability for higher weight ranges.

Casper mattresses range from 10-13 inches in height, while Leesa offers similar profiles between 10-12 inches. This moderate mattress height works with standard sheets but may feel low for some aesthetic preferences or those who prefer a taller bed.

Fawcett's mattresses are designed with all body types in mind, with enhanced support cores that prevent premature sagging even with heavier sleepers.

Temperature Regulation

Temperature regulation remains a challenge for many foam mattresses. Casper attempts to address this with perforated foam layers, but many users still report heat retention issues, especially in their all-foam models.

Leesa performs slightly better in cooling tests, particularly in their hybrid models where airflow through the coil layers helps dissipate heat. Their proprietary Avena foam also sleeps cooler than traditional memory foam.

Our natural approach at Fawcett leverages the inherent cooling properties of latex, which has an open-cell structure that allows for significantly better airflow than synthetic foams. When combined with breathable organic cotton covers and moisture-wicking wool comfort layers, our mattresses maintain a neutral sleep temperature throughout the night.

Leesa vs Casper: Price, Value, and Affordability

Both Casper and Leesa position themselves in the mid-range market. Queen-sized mattresses generally range from $1,300-2,200 CAD, depending on the model and current promotions. Hybrid versions typically command a $300-500 premium over all-foam counterparts.

While neither brand can be considered budget options, their direct-to-consumer model eliminates retail markups, offering reasonable value. However, concerns about the longevity of foam mattresses—which typically begin to show significant compression after 5-7 years—affect their long-term value proposition.

At Fawcett, we focus on creating mattresses that maintain their integrity for significantly longer periods. While our natural latex hybrid mattresses may represent a slightly higher initial investment, their extended lifespan (often 15+ years) provides superior long-term value while supporting Canadian craftsmanship.

Casper and Leesa Mattress Warranty and Return Policy

Trial Periods and Returns

Both Casper and Leesa offer 100-night sleep trials, requiring a minimum 30-night break-in period before returns. Casper provides free returns within Canada, coordinating mattress pickup and donation when possible. Leesa charges a $100 return fee for Canadian customers, which can be a significant consideration.

Warranty Coverage

Both brands offer 10-year limited warranties covering manufacturing defects and excessive sagging (typically defined as indentations greater than 1 inch). Casper covers shipping costs for repairs or replacements, while Leesa requires customers to pay shipping fees, which can be substantial for Canadian customers.

At Fawcett, we stand behind our mattresses with a 10-year warranty and a 100-Night Comfort Exchange Policy. We believe in the quality of our handcrafted products and make the exchange process simple if you're not completely satisfied.

Other Important Factors When Choosing Between Leesa and Casper

Canadian Considerations

Casper has established a stronger Canadian presence, with products available through Sleep Country Canada and other retailers. Leesa operates primarily online for Canadian customers, which can limit opportunities to test before purchasing.

Canadian customers should also consider shipping costs, delivery times, and potential customs or duty fees, especially for warranty claims that might involve cross-border shipping.

Environmental Impact

Both Casper and Leesa use CertiPUR-US certified foams, ensuring their products are free from certain harmful chemicals. However, the petroleum-based materials used in foam mattresses raise concerns about sustainability and end-of-life disposal.

At Fawcett, we prioritize sustainability by using natural, renewable materials like latex harvested from rubber trees without harming the tree itself. Our mattresses contain minimal synthetic materials, resulting in a product that's better for both you and the environment.

Natural Alternatives: The Fawcett Difference

If you're considering Casper and Leesa, you might also want to explore our handcrafted natural alternatives. Our latex hybrid mattresses offer several advantages:

1. Natural Materials: We use genuine latex rather than synthetic foam alternatives, creating a healthier sleep environment free from chemical off-gassing.
2. Superior Durability: Natural latex maintains its integrity for 15-20 years, significantly outlasting synthetic foams that begin to compress after just a few years.
3. Better Temperature Regulation: The open-cell structure of latex combined with breathable organic cotton and wool creates naturally temperature-neutral sleeping conditions.
4. Customizable Comfort: Rather than a one-size-fits-all approach, we craft mattresses to your specific comfort preferences.
5. Canadian Craftsmanship: Our mattresses are handcrafted in Victoria, BC, supporting local economy and ensuring exceptional quality control.

For more comparisons, take a look at our deep dive into the Endy, Douglas, and Casper differences, a closer look at the Purple vs GhostBed showdown, or see how Puffy stacks up against Casper.

FAQs

What is better than the Casper mattress?

For sleepers seeking enhanced durability and natural materials, our Fawcett hybrid latex mattresses offer a compelling alternative to Casper. Natural latex provides similar pressure relief but with better temperature regulation and significantly longer lifespan. For those with specific needs like enhanced cooling or targeted support, our customizable options allow for a more tailored sleep experience than Casper's standardized models.

Is Costco Casper the same as the original Casper?

No, the Casper Select sold at Costco differs from the original Casper mattress. The Select features a slightly different foam composition and thickness, generally offering firmer support and better edge support. However, it maintains Casper's signature zoned support system while being exclusive to Costco members at a lower price point than direct-from-Casper options.

Is Nectar or Casper a better mattress?

Nectar and Casper cater to different needs. Nectar offers a medium-firm memory foam feel with deeper contouring and a longer warranty (lifetime vs. Casper's 10 years). Casper provides more responsive foam with zoned support that many back sleepers prefer. For those seeking a natural alternative to both, our latex mattresses offer the pressure relief of memory foam with the responsiveness of latex and none of the synthetic materials.

Which sleeps cooler, Casper or Leesa?

Generally, Leesa mattresses sleep slightly cooler than comparable Casper models. Leesa's Avena foam top layer has better breathability than Casper's polyfoam, while both brands' hybrid models offer improved temperature regulation over their all-foam counterparts. However, neither compares to the natural cooling properties of genuine latex used in our Fawcett mattresses, which provides superior airflow and temperature neutrality.

How do all foam mattresses compare to hybrid models?

All foam mattresses typically excel in motion isolation and pressure relief but may trap heat and lack edge support. The Casper Original and Leesa Original are prime examples of this trade-off. Hybrid mattresses combine foam comfort layers with supportive coil systems, offering better airflow, enhanced edge support, and improved durability. For combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night, the responsive nature of hybrid models often provides better overall comfort and support.

Do side sleepers need a softer mattress than back sleepers?

Yes, most side sleepers benefit from a softer mattress with excellent pressure relief to accommodate shoulder and hip pressure points. Leesa's medium firmness (5-6/10) often works well for side sleepers, while the medium-firm feel of the Casper mattress (6-7/10) typically suits back sleepers better. The ideal firmness ultimately depends on your body weight and personal preference. Heavier side sleepers might prefer a medium-firm mattress, while lighter back sleepers might find comfort in a medium option.

Does the breathable cover on these mattresses help with temperature regulation?

A breathable cover contributes to temperature regulation but isn't sufficient on its own. Casper uses a breathable top layer with perforated foam in some models, while Leesa incorporates a breathable cover with their proprietary Avena foam that helps dissipate heat. However, the core construction matters more for hot sleepers. Our Fawcett mattresses feature naturally breathable materials throughout, including wool comfort layers that actively wick moisture away, ensuring mattresses sleep cool throughout the night.

What should I know about the firmness scale when comparing mattresses?

The mattress industry uses a 1-10 firmness scale, with 1 being extremely soft and 10 being extremely firm. Most comfortable mattresses fall between 4-8. Casper trends toward medium-firm (6-7), while Leesa offers a medium feel (5-6). When testing mattresses, consider how your sleeping position affects your needs. Stomach sleepers typically need a firmer mattress for proper spinal alignment, while side sleepers benefit from softer surfaces that allow shoulder and hip sinking.

Do I need a box spring with the Casper or Leesa mattress?

Neither Casper nor Leesa requires a traditional box spring. Both mattresses work well on platform beds, slatted bases (with slats no more than 3-4 inches apart), adjustable foundations, or directly on the floor. If you're using an older box spring with a Queen size mattress or larger, consider adding a bunkie board for more adequate support. At Fawcett, we provide guidance on compatible foundations with every mattress purchase to ensure optimal support and warranty compliance.

How does the Casper Original Mattress compare to newer Casper models?

The Casper Original Mattress established the brand with its three foam layers and medium-firm feel. Newer models like the Wave and Nova offer additional features such as more advanced zoned support layers, gel pods for targeted support, and enhanced cooling technologies. The firmer feel of the original works well for back and stomach sleepers, while newer options might provide better comfort for side sleepers and hot sleepers. However, these additional features come at a higher price point, sometimes 30-50% more than the Original.

How does body weight affect the choice between Leesa vs Casper?

Body weight significantly impacts how a mattress feels. For sleepers under 130 pounds, Leesa's softer surface often provides better comfort as lighter individuals don't sink as deeply into firmer mattresses to experience pressure relief. Average-weight sleepers (130-230 pounds) may find both brands comfortable, depending on their sleeping position. Heavier individuals (over 230 pounds) might find that both Leesa and Casper's all-foam beds lack enough support for long-term comfort and should consider hybrid options with more supportive coil systems for better spinal alignment and mattress longevity.

The Takeaway

When comparing Casper and Leesa mattresses, your choice ultimately depends on your specific sleep preferences. Casper's zoned support works well for back sleepers seeking firmer lumbar support, while Leesa's uniform comfort layer appeals to side sleepers needing consistent pressure relief.

However, both brands rely on synthetic foam materials that raise questions about durability, temperature regulation, and environmental impact. At Fawcett Mattress, we believe there's a better way to sleep. Our crafted latex mattresses combine the pressure relief you want with the natural materials your body deserves.

Whether you choose Casper, Leesa, or explore our natural alternatives, understanding these key differences helps ensure you find the perfect mattress for your needs. We invite you to contact our mattress experts to learn more about how our handcrafted approach can transform your sleep experience.