Douglas Mattress vs Casper: A Complete Comparison for Canadian Shoppers

When shopping for a new mattress in Canada, you're likely to encounter two popular bed-in-a-box brands: Douglas mattress vs Casper. Both offer foam mattress options delivered to your door, but they differ significantly in construction, feel, price, and policies. As a Canadian company ourselves, we understand how challenging it can be to choose the right sleep surface, especially when you can't try it before buying.

Today, we're comparing these two mattress giants to help you understand which might better suit your sleep needs and provide a good night's sleep. We'll also share how our crafted natural and organic mattresses at Fawcett offer distinct advantages over conventional memory foam mattresses for those seeking premium sleep quality and environmental consciousness.

Douglas vs Casper Mattress Full Comparison Table

What is the Distinction Between Casper and Douglas Mattress?

The primary difference between Douglas mattress and Casper mattress lies in their market positioning and business models. Douglas is a proudly Canadian company that focuses on providing exceptional value through a simplified approach to selling mattresses online. Their mattress is specifically designed for Canadian sleepers and made entirely in Canada.

Casper vs. Douglas represents a contrast in origin. Casper, originally an American company, has established a significant presence in Canada. They offer a wider range of mattress options at higher price points, leveraging their global brand recognition and extensive marketing.

While both companies sell foam mattresses, they each take different approaches to materials, design philosophy, and customer policies, resulting in distinct sleep experiences and value propositions.

We at Fawcett take a fundamentally different approach than either Douglas or Casper. Rather than using synthetic foams, we make our mattresses in Victoria, BC using natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and natural wool. Our focus is on creating healthier sleep environments with materials that breathe better, last longer, and contain no harmful chemicals.

Mattress Construction

Douglas Mattress Construction

The Douglas mattress features a streamlined three-layer all-foam design:

1. Top Layer: 2 inches of ecoLight® cooling gel foam that offers pressure point relief with a 40% lower carbon footprint than traditional memory foam
2. Middle Layer: 2 inches of Elastex® foam providing latex-like responsiveness without allergens
3. Base Layer: 6 inches of motion isolation support foam for stability and durability
4. Cover: CoolSense® cover made from Tencel® and Infinitex™ fibers that's removable and machine washable

At 10 inches thick, the Douglas mattress balances contouring comfort with proper support, particularly for back and combination sleepers with different sleep styles.

Casper Mattress Construction

The Casper mattress employs a more complex construction:

1. Top Layer: 1.5 inches of perforated foam for breathability
2. Middle Foam Layer: 2 inches of zoned memory foam with three ergonomic zones
3. Base Layer: 7 inches of supportive high-density memory foam
4. Cover: Knit fabric blend that's non-removable and spot-clean only

At 11 inches tall, the Casper focuses on targeted support using its zoned support system, which is firmer under the hips and softer under the shoulders and legs.

How Our Natural Mattresses Compare

At Fawcett, we take a fundamentally different approach with natural materials that deliver superior comfort and health benefits:

• Our Sombrio Natural Latex Mattress: We craft this 7" mattress with pure natural Talalay latex layers and no synthetic foams, wrapped in organic cotton and natural wool
• Our Galiano Natural Latex Mattress: Our 10.5" premium natural latex mattress features customizable firmness options
• Our Cumberland Hybrid Latex Mattress: We combine 12.5" of natural latex over pocketed coils for exceptional pressure relief

Unlike foam beds, which can trap body heat and off-gas chemicals, our natural materials breathe better and contain no harmful substances, providing a healthier sleep environment with better temperature regulation for cooler sleep.

Check out the key differences between Emma and Casper to see which mattress suits your sleep style best.

Mattress Features

Firmness and Feel

Douglas offers a medium firm mattress feel (6.7/10 on the firmness scale) that balances support and pressure relief. The ecoLight® foam contours to your body without the excessive "sink" of traditional memory foam, while the Elastex® layer provides responsive support.

Casper delivers a medium feel (5.5/10) with its zoned support system. The mattress feels softer under the shoulders and firmer under the hips, creating ergonomic alignment. This targeted approach works particularly well for side sleepers with back pain concerns.

Our Fawcett mattresses offer customizable firmness options—soft, medium firm, and firm—allowing you to select your perfect feel. Our Galiano and Cumberland mattresses even offer dual firmness options with different feels on each side for couples with different preferences. Unlike foam that can soften over time, our natural Talalay latex maintains its supportive resilience for years.

Cooling Technology

Douglas incorporates cooling gel in its top layer and a breathable Tencel® cover to dissipate heat. The ecoLight® foam has an open-cell structure that improves air circulation compared to traditional memory foam.

Casper uses perforated foam to create channels for heat to escape. While effective for a foam mattress, some users still report heat retention issues in warmer weather.

Our approach at Fawcett is to use materials that naturally help you stay cool without special additives. Our Talalay latex has an inherently open-cell structure that allows for substantial airflow. We enhance this with moisture-wicking wool and breathable organic cotton covers, creating a sleep surface that provides superior temperature regulation naturally.

Edge Support

Edge support determines how well a mattress performs when you sit or sleep near its perimeter—an important consideration for couples sharing a bed or anyone who uses the entire sleep surface.

Douglas performs surprisingly well for a foam mattress, with an edge support rating of 7.8/10. The high-density base foam prevents excessive compression around the edges.

Casper's edge support is adequate (7.5/10) but less impressive than Douglas's, with some users reporting sagging around the perimeter over time. According to mattress reviews, the latter offers better edge support.

Our hybrid models like the Nootka and Cumberland offer exceptional edge support thanks to our reinforced pocketed coil systems, allowing full use of the sleep surface. Even our all-latex models maintain their structural integrity at the edges better than foam mattresses, giving you more usable sleep surface.

Motion Isolation and Pressure Relief

Motion isolation prevents movement from transferring across the mattress—a crucial feature for couples where one partner is a light sleeper or moves frequently during the night.

Douglas excels in motion isolation with a rating of 8.3/10. Its motion isolation support foam effectively absorbs movement, making it an excellent choice for couples.

Casper performs adequately but not exceptionally in this category (6.6/10), with some motion transfer noticeable across the surface.

Our natural latex mattresses provide excellent motion isolation while still maintaining responsiveness. Unlike memory foam that can feel "stuck," our latex responds quickly to movement while still minimizing disturbance between sleep partners. This gives you the best of both worlds—isolation without feeling trapped.

For pressure point relief, all three brands perform well, but through different approaches:

• Douglas uses conforming ecoLight® foam to relieve pressure points
• Casper employs zoned support to create targeted pressure relief
• We utilize the natural elasticity of Talalay latex to gently cradle pressure points without creating the "stuck" feeling often associated with memory foam

Bed and Accessories

Douglas offers limited accessories, though their mattress is compatible with most foundations, including adjustable bases. Some promotions may include a comfort sleep bundle with your mattress purchase.

Casper has expanded into a full sleep brand with pillows, sheets, bed frame options, and even a glow light. Their accessory prices tend to be premium.

We provide a complete sleep system with complementary products made with the same natural philosophy:

• Our natural latex pillows maintain proper alignment
• Our Australian wool bedding regulates temperature naturally
• Our organic cotton sheets enhance breathability
• Our solid wood bed frames are handcrafted in Canada

We've designed our accessories to work together as a complete sleep system, enhancing the performance of our mattresses while maintaining our commitment to natural materials.

Sleep Trial and Returns

Douglas offers one of the most generous policies in Canada with a 365-night sleep trial. They require you to try the mattress for at least 30 days before initiating a return. Returns are free with a full refund, with the company arranging pickup for returned mattresses.

Casper provides a 100-night sleep trial period with the same 30-day mandatory trial period. While returns are free, customers who purchase through third-party retailers may encounter different return policies.

We offer a 100-night comfort exchange, allowing you to adjust your mattress's firmness if your initial choice isn't perfect. This unique approach reduces waste and ensures you get the right comfort level without the hassle of a full return. We believe this practical approach provides real value while being environmentally responsible.

Comfort and Value

When considering comfort relative to price, Douglas mattress offers exceptional value at $799 for a Queen, delivering performance comparable to mattresses costing nearly twice as much. It's not an expensive mattress yet provides many premium features.

Casper mattress, at $1,499 for a Queen, positions itself as a premium option but doesn't necessarily deliver proportionally better comfort or durability to justify the price difference.

Our Fawcett mattresses represent an investment in superior materials and craftsmanship. Our Sombrio Natural Latex Mattress starts at $1,999 for a Queen, while our Goldstream Hybrid starts at just $1,399. While this represents a higher initial investment than the Douglas, the superior durability of our natural latex (often lasting 15-20 years compared to 7-10 for foam) makes them more economical in the long run than traditional innerspring mattresses or foam options.

How to Choose the Right Mattress for Your Sleep Needs

Selecting the ideal mattress depends on several personal factors:

For Side Sleepers: Look for excellent pressure relief to cushion shoulders and hips.

• Douglas: Good option with its conforming ecoLight® foam
• Casper: Well-suited with its zoned support system
• Our Recommendation: Our Galiano in medium firmness offers perfect pressure relief without excessive sinkage

For Back and Stomach Sleepers: Prioritize spinal alignment and support.

• Douglas: Good support from its responsive Elastex® foam
• Casper: Adequate support but may soften over time
• Our Recommendation: Our Sombrio in firm configuration provides ideal support that won't soften prematurely

For Couples: Consider motion isolation and edge support.

• Douglas: Excellent motion isolation, good edge support
• Casper: Moderate motion isolation, adequate edge support
• Our Recommendation: Our Cumberland Hybrid offers the perfect balance of motion isolation with exceptional edge support

For Hot Sleepers: Focus on cooling properties.

• Douglas: Good cooling through gel-infused foam
• Casper: Moderate cooling with perforated foam
• Our Recommendation: Any of our natural latex mattresses will sleep significantly cooler thanks to our wool, cotton, and naturally breathable latex

Customer Experience and Support

Douglas mattress has established a strong reputation for customer service, with responsive support and straightforward policies. This Canadian company means they understand local needs and shipping logistics.

Casper mattress pioneered many aspects of the mattress in a box experience but has received mixed reviews for customer service in recent years. Some Canadian customers report delays with warranty claims and inconsistent support.

We at Fawcett offer a personalized customer experience with our mattress experts available to help you select the perfect sleep system for your needs. As a Canadian company handcrafting mattresses in Victoria, BC, we understand Canadians' unique needs and preferences, providing responsive service and support throughout your mattress ownership.

Environmental and Sustainability Practices

Douglas demonstrates commitment to sustainability with Canadian manufacturing (reducing shipping emissions), ecoLight® foam with a 40% lower carbon footprint, and renewable energy in manufacturing.

Casper has made incremental improvements in sustainability, using some recycled materials in covers and CertiPUR-US® certified foams, but still relies primarily on petroleum-based materials.

We take a fundamentally different approach, using natural and renewable materials:

• Natural Talalay latex tapped from rubber trees (a renewable resource)
• Organic cotton grown without pesticides
• Natural wool that's sustainable and biodegradable
• Zero synthetic foams or chemical flame retardants

Our mattresses are handcrafted in Victoria, BC, minimizing transportation emissions and supporting local craftsmanship and the Canadian economy.

If you're comparing more options, explore our head-to-head reviews of the Puffy vs Casper and Purple vs Tempur-Pedic, or learn how sleep habits across the country impact mattress choices in our Canadian sleep statistics guide.

Also read: Douglas vs Emma Mattress

FAQs

Are Douglas mattresses any good?

Yes, the Douglas mattress today offers excellent value for Canadian sleepers. They provide good pressure relief, motion isolation, and cooling at a competitive price point. As a Canadian-made product, they're designed specifically for our climate and preferences, with policies that make sense for Canadian consumers.

What is the Canadian version of Casper?

While Casper operates in Canada, Douglas is often considered the "Canadian Casper" — created specifically for Canadian sleepers and manufactured entirely in Canada. Douglas offers many similar benefits to Casper at a significantly lower price point, with a longer warranty and sleep trial.

Which mattress is the best in Canada?

The "best" mattress depends on your specific needs, but for those seeking natural materials, superior durability, and handcrafted quality, our Fawcett latex and hybrid mattresses represent the premium choice in Canada. For those prioritizing value in a foam mattress, Douglas delivers exceptional performance for the price. Casper remains popular due to its brand recognition, though it's outperformed in many categories by both Douglas and our Fawcett options.

Key Takeaways

1. Douglas mattress offers superior value in the foam mattress category, with Canadian manufacturing, excellent motion isolation, and the longest sleep trial in the industry at a competitive price point. Choosing Douglas means getting a winning mattress at a fraction of the cost of other premium brands.
2. Casper provides good zoned support but at a significantly higher price point, with shorter warranty and trial periods compared to Douglas.
3. Our Fawcett natural latex and hybrid mattresses represent a step up in quality and materials, using natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and wool instead of synthetic foams for a healthier, more durable sleep surface.
4. Consider your primary sleep needs when choosing: Douglas for value, Casper for zoned support, or our Fawcett mattresses for natural materials and superior durability.
5. Policies matter: Douglas leads with its 365-night trial and 15-year warranty, while we offer a unique 100-night comfort exchange that allows you to adjust your mattress's firmness rather than replacing it entirely.

Whether you choose a foam mattress like Douglas or Casper or invest in one of our natural latex or hybrid mattresses from Fawcett, understanding these key differences will help you make an informed decision for years of restful, comfortable sleep. Don't let your old mattress prevent you from getting the quality rest you deserve.

Contact us to speak with a mattress expert about finding your perfect sleep solution today.