Endy vs Douglas vs Casper Mattress Canada: Is There a Better Choice?

When you're searching for the perfect mattress in Canada, you'll likely encounter these three popular bed-in-a-box options: Endy, Douglas, and Casper mattress brands. Each has captured a significant slice of the Canadian mattress market with their convenient online shopping experience and compressed delivery method. But how do they really compare, and is there possibly a better alternative for Canadian sleepers?

As mattress experts who handcraft natural sleep solutions right here on Vancouver Island, we've created this comprehensive comparison to help you understand what these mainstream options offer—and what they might be missing. We'll examine construction, comfort, support features, and value to help you make the most informed decision for your bedroom.

Comparison Table: Endy vs Douglas vs Casper Mattress

What Are Their Key Differences?

The most striking differences between these three mattresses lie in their construction, materials, and approach to sleep comfort. Let's break down these differences to understand what each mattress offers Canadian sleepers.

Mattress Construction and Materials

Endy

The Endy mattress features a simple three-layer all-foam design with a total height of 10 inches. The top layer consists of 2 inches of their proprietary Endy Comfort Foam, which is gel-infused to help with cooling. Below that is a 3-inch transition polyfoam layer, followed by a 5-inch high-density support foam base. The mattress is wrapped in a removable, machine-washable polyester-blend mattress cover.

Douglas

The Douglas mattress also utilizes a three-layer construction, but with more eco-conscious materials. The top layer features 2 inches of ecoLight® cooling gel foam, which has a 40% lower carbon footprint than traditional memory foam. The middle layer is 2 inches of Elastex® foam, a latex alternative that provides bounce without common latex allergens. The foundation is 6 inches of motion isolation support foam. Its cover is made from sustainable Infinitex™ fibres derived from eucalyptus.

Casper

The Casper Original consists of three layers totalling 11 inches. The top layer is their AirScape™ perforated foam with thousands of small holes to increase airflow. The middle layer is zoned memory foam that's softer under the shoulders and firmer around the hips and lower back. The base is 7 inches of durable support foam. Casper's cover is made from recycled bottles but isn't removable.

Fawcett: A Natural Alternative

In contrast to these synthetic foam mattresses options, our crafted mattresses at Fawcett use 100% natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and Joma wool. Our hybrid models like the Goldstream combine the pressure relief of natural latex with the support of individually wrapped coils, while our all-latex options like the Sombrio provide incredible durability and natural comfort without springs.

Support and Firmness

Endy

The Endy mattress offers a medium-firm mattress feel, rated around 5.7/10 on the firmness scale. It provides a balanced level of support that works well for side sleepers and back sleepers under 230 lbs. The transition layer helps prevent sleepers from sinking too deeply into the mattress.

Douglas

With a slightly firmer feel (6.7/10), the Douglas mattress provides more support for back and stomach sleepers. Its Elastex® foam layer adds responsiveness, creating a more "floating" sensation compared to the deeper hug of traditional memory foam. This makes it particularly suitable for combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night.

Casper

Casper offers the softest feel among the three, with a medium rating of about 4.8/10. Its zoned support system provides targeted pressure relief, being softer under the shoulders and firmer under the hips, which helps with spinal alignment for side sleepers, especially.

Fawcett: Customizable Support

What sets our Fawcett mattresses apart is the ability to personalize firmness levels to your exact preference. Our natural latex provides exceptional pressure relief while maintaining proper spinal alignment. Unlike foam that compresses and develops body impressions over time, natural latex maintains its resilience and supportive properties for decades.

Pressure Relief and Comfort

All three mattresses provide good pressure relief, but they accomplish this differently:

• Endy's comfort layer offers a balance of contouring and responsiveness, good for most sleeping positions.
• Douglas's ecoLight® foam provides gentle cradling with quicker response time than traditional memory foam.
• Casper's zoned design targets pressure points more specifically, with softer foam around the shoulders and firmer support under the hips.

At Fawcett, our natural Talalay latex delivers superior pressure point relief without the sinking feeling of foam. The inherent elasticity of latex provides the perfect balance of gentle cushioning and buoyant support, conforming to your body while keeping your spine properly aligned.

Motion Isolation and Cooling

Motion Isolation

Douglas mattress leads in motion isolation with its dense base foam earning an 8.3/10 rating in independent testing. This makes it excellent for couples or light sleepers. Endy performs well too (7.8/10), while Casper's softer construction allows slightly more motion transfer.

Cooling Properties

Temperature regulation is a common concern with foam mattresses:

• Douglas performs best with its cooling gel foam and breathable Infinitex™ cover, reducing sleep temperature by up to 2.8°C in testing.
• Endy uses gel-infused open-cell foam to dissipate heat, achieving around 2.1°C temperature reduction.
• Casper's AirScape™ design with perforations helps with airflow but tends to trap more heat than Douglas.

Our Fawcett hybrid and latex mattresses naturally excel at temperature regulation. The open-cell structure of natural Talalay latex allows continuous airflow, while our Joma wool layer naturally wicks away moisture and regulates body temperature year-round. Unlike synthetic foams that trap heat, our natural materials keep you cool in summer and warm in winter.

Pricing and Value

Price Points

Douglas offers the best value at $799 for a queen, followed by Endy at $895, and Casper at $1,295+ for their basic model. Casper's hybrid versions can exceed $1,600.

Douglas enhances its value with free bedding bundles (sheets, protector, pillows) during promotions, effectively reducing the overall cost by $300+.

Sleep Trial and Returns

Douglas stands out with an industry-leading 365-night sleep trial, while both Endy and Casper offer standard 100-night trials. All three companies provide free returns with full refunds after you've tested the mattress for at least 30 days.

Warranty Coverage

Warranty protection varies significantly:

• Douglas: 15-20 years (sources differ)
• Endy: 15 years
• Casper: 10 years

Our Fawcett mattresses start from $999 for our hybrid mattresses like the Goldstream, and we back every mattress with a 10-year warranty. We offer a 100-night sleep trial with free returns, and we're proud to offer free shipping across Canada on our mattresses.

Customer Reviews and Brand Reputation

All three brands maintain positive customer reviews, but with different strengths:

• Endy receives praise for customer service and Canadian manufacturing.
• Douglas earns high marks for value, cooling properties, and eco-friendly materials.
• Casper is noted for its brand recognition and zoned support system.

At Fawcett Mattress, we've built our reputation on handcrafted quality and natural materials. Our customers consistently highlight the superior comfort, durability, and health benefits of sleeping on natural latex instead of synthetic foams.

Best Mattress for Sleep Position and Body Type

Sleep Position

• Side Sleepers: Casper's zoned support works well for side sleepers, as does Endy's medium-firm feel.
• Back Sleepers: Douglas's firmer feel often suits back sleepers better, providing adequate lumbar support.
• Stomach Sleepers: Douglas offers the firmest option, which generally works better for stomach sleepers.
• Combination Sleepers: Douglas's responsive Elastex® layer facilitates easier movement.

Body Type

• Under 130 lbs: Casper's softer feel prevents pressure points for lightweight sleepers.
• 130-230 lbs: All three mattresses perform well in this range, with personal preference being the deciding factor.
• Over 230 lbs: None of these all-foam models are ideal for heavier individuals, who might find better support with Fawcett's hybrid latex mattresses like the Cumberland or Nootka.

Pros and Cons of Each Mattress

Endy

Pros:

• Made in Canada
• Removable, washable cover
• Balanced medium-firm feel

Cons:

• Limited firmness options
• Less cooling than Douglas
• Shorter sleep trial than Douglas

Douglas

Pros:

• Best value pricing
• 365-night sleep trial
• Superior cooling properties
• Eco-friendly materials

Cons:

• May be too firm for some side sleepers
• Limited availability outside Canada

Casper

Pros:

• Specialized zoned support
• Good for side sleepers
• Widely available

Cons:

• Most expensive option
• Shortest warranty (10 years)
• Not made in Canada

Fawcett (Natural Alternative)

Pros:

• 100% natural materials
• Customizable firmness options
• Superior durability (15+ years)
• Excellent temperature regulation
• Made in Canada (Victoria, BC)

Cons:

• Higher price point than foam-based options
• Heavier and more difficult to move

FAQs

Is the Douglas mattress better than Endy?

The Douglas mattress offers better value with a lower price point, longer sleep trial (365 nights vs. 100), and superior cooling properties. However, Endy may be preferable for those who want a slightly softer feel and a removable cover.

Which mattress is better, Endy or Casper?

Endy vs Casper comparison shows Endy offers better value with a lower price point ($895 vs. $1,295 for queen) and longer warranty (15 years vs. 10), while being made in Canada. Casper's zoned support may provide better pressure relief for side sleepers, but at a premium price.

What mattress is better than Casper?

Douglas vs Casper comparison reveals Douglas offers better value with similar performance at a significantly lower price. For those seeking natural materials and greater durability, Fawcett's natural latex mattresses provide superior longevity, temperature regulation, and customizable comfort without harmful chemicals.

What is the best mattress to buy in Canada?

The "best" mattress depends on your specific needs and preferences. Douglas offers excellent value in the foam mattress category. However, if you're looking for natural materials and longer-lasting comfort, we believe our Fawcett natural latex mattresses offer superior quality, health benefits, and durability over synthetic foam options.

How do memory foam mattresses compare to other mattress types?

Memory foam mattresses like those from Endy and Casper contour to your body and excel at pressure point relief. They typically offer good motion isolation but may retain body heat more than other materials. The comfort layer in these mattresses adapts to your shape but can sometimes make changing positions difficult. In comparison, natural latex provides resilient support with better cooling and durability.

Can I use these mattresses with any bed frame?

Yes, all three mattresses work with most bed frame types, including platform beds, slatted frames (with slats less than 3 inches apart), and adjustable bases. Douglas bed performance is especially good on various foundations. When choosing a bed frame, ensure it provides adequate support for your new mattress to prevent sagging and maintain warranty coverage.

Are these mattresses good for hot sleepers?

For hot sleepers concerned about overheating, Douglas offers the best cooling performance among the three with its cooling gel and breathable cover. The open-cell memory foam layer in Endy helps with air circulation, while Casper's perforated top layer attempts to promote cooler sleep. However, all foam mattresses tend to sleep warmer than natural materials. For the most effective temperature regulation and a truly cool night's sleep, our natural latex mattresses provide superior breathability.

How are rolled up mattresses delivered and set up?

Each of these three mattresses arrives as a mattress in a box, compressed and rolled for easier shipping. After purchasing online, the mattress is delivered to your door, where you'll need to bring it to your bedroom, carefully unbox it, and allow it to expand for 24-48 hours before sleeping on it. This convenient delivery method has revolutionized mattress shopping, though the mattress purchase experience lacks the traditional in-store testing offered at retailers like Sleep Country Canada.

How important is edge support in these mattresses?

Edge support varies among these options, with Douglas providing good edge support compared to other all-foam beds. Casper's edge support is adequate but may compress more when sitting on the perimeter. Endy falls somewhere in between. Edge support is important if you frequently sit on the bed's edge or use the entire sleep surface. Our hybrid mattresses combine the comfort of latex with reinforced perimeters for superior edge support throughout the entire mattress.

Will these mattresses help me get a good night's sleep?

All three mattresses can provide a good night's sleep for the right sleeper. The Douglas Original works well for back and combination sleepers, while Endy's balanced feel accommodates various sleep styles. Casper's zoned design targets pressure points for side sleepers. For the most restful sleep experience, match your mattress to your specific sleep position, weight, temperature preferences, and any issues like back pain. Remember that mattress reviews can help guide your decision, but personal comfort preferences vary widely.

In Summary

Each of these popular boxed mattresses has its strengths: Endy vs Douglas vs Casper mattress comparison shows Endy offers Canadian-made balance, Douglas provides exceptional value and cooling, while Casper brings zoned support at a premium price. However, all three use synthetic foams that eventually compress and lose their supportive properties.

For those seeking a truly natural sleep experience with exceptional longevity, our handcrafted mattresses at Fawcett offer an excellent alternative. Made with 100% natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and Joma wool, our mattresses provide superior pressure relief, temperature regulation, and durability compared to foam-based options.

Whether you choose our all-latex models like the Sombrio or our hybrid designs like the Cumberland, you'll experience the difference that natural materials and expert craftsmanship make in your sleep quality. Contact us to speak with a mattress expert about finding your perfect natural sleep solution.

To dive deeper into the topic, check out our article on how Canadians are sleeping, a detailed comparison of the Casper and Leesa mattresses, and a breakdown of the Purple vs GhostBed differences.