Simba vs Casper Mattress Canada: Complete Comparison Guide

When choosing between two of Canada's most popular bed-in-a-box brands, the decision often comes down to Simba or Casper. Both brands have carved significant market presence in Canada, yet they approach sleep technology with distinctly different philosophies. This comprehensive mattress review examines every aspect of these sleep products to help Canadian sleepers make the right mattress purchase.

Key Takeaways

• Simba focuses on a hybrid mattress construction with proprietary Aerocoil microcoils, offering firmer support (7/10 on the firmness scale), excellent edge support, and cooling via graphite-infused foam.
• Casper offers a versatile all-foam mattress with zoned support, delivering medium comfort, superior motion isolation, and pressure relief.
• Pricing varies significantly: Simba Hybrid Original at C$1,699-1,799, Casper One at C$849-999, while Casper’s full line ranges from C$594-2,974
• Construction differences are substantial: Simba uses 2,500 micro coils in a 5-layer hybrid design, while Casper employs a 3-layer all-foam with breathable technologies.
• Sleep Trial periods match at 100 nights with free returns, but warranties differ: both offer 10-year warranties, with Casper providing more specialized cooling options in its premium models.

Simba vs Casper Mattress Comparison Table

What Sets Simba and Casper Apart?

The fundamental difference lies in their engineering philosophy. Simba builds around hybrid technology featuring thousands of pocketed micro springs combined with memory foam, while Casper prioritizes all-foam construction with strategic zoning for pressure relief.

Simba's approach stems from analyzing body profile data from over ten million sleepers worldwide, creating what they call the "Goldilocks" mattress—not too soft, not too firm, but just right. This philosophy translates into their signature Aerocoil system with 2,500 individual springs that respond independently to body movements.

Casper takes a different route, focusing on simplified sleep solutions. Their "no-brainer" approach emphasizes accessibility and broad appeal by carefully engineered foam layers that deliver balanced comfort across most sleeping positions.

How Do Simba and Casper Mattresses Differ in Construction and Materials?

Simba Hybrid Construction

Simba's 5-layer construction creates a sophisticated sleep system that mattresses tested in independent reviews consistently rate highly:

1. Hypoallergenic Knitted Top Cover (520g) - Promotes breathability and hygiene.
2. Simbatex memory foam Comfort Layer (1.25") - Graphite-infused open-cell foam for cooling
3. Aerocoil Spring Support Layer (1") - 2,500 pocketed micro for responsive support
4. Stabilizing Core Support Foam - Bridges comfort and support layers
5. 7-Zone Support Foundation (7.75") - CertiPUR-certified high density foam

Casper One Construction

Casper's streamlined three-layer approach focuses on essentials:

1. Soft Knit Top Cover - Cozy fabric blend for surface comfort
2. Breathe Flex Polyurethane Foam (2") - Perforated open-cell foam with cooling channels
3. Align Memory Foam Second Layer (2") - Zoned support for pressure point relief
4. Casper Core Bottom Layer (7") - High-density foam foundation

The key difference? Casper's zoned memory foam provides softer support for shoulders and firmer resistance for hips, while Simba achieves similar body-specific support through spring responsiveness.

Which Mattress Has Better Layers?

The answer depends on your priorities. Simba's 5-layer system provides more transitional zones between soft comfort and firm support, creating a gradually changing feel that many find natural. The micro coil layer adds responsiveness that foam alone cannot match.

Casper's 3-layer approach offers elegance through simplicity. With fewer material interfaces, there's less potential for layer separation over time. The specialized foam formulations deliver targeted benefits without unnecessary complexity.

For combination sleepers who frequently change positions, Simba's spring layer offers better responsiveness. For pressure-sensitive side sleepers, Casper's memory foam contouring offers superior pressure relief.

How Do the Simba & Casper Mattresses Compare in Firmness and Feel?

• Simba 2500: Testing reveals a firm 7/10 on the firmness scale, with minimal "hug" or sinking. You'll feel supported "on top" of the bed rather than cradled within it. This firmness suits back sleepers and stomach sleepers who need consistent spinal alignment.
• Casper One: Rates 6.5/10 for medium firm feel with moderate contouring. The current model offers more balanced support than previous versions, accommodating various sleeping positions while providing gentle pressure relief.

The difference is significant. Simba feels more like sleeping on a responsive, supportive platform with less bounce. At the same time, Casper uses responsive polyurethane foams that mimic memory foam contouring without a deep sink-in feel.

Which Mattress Offers Better Cooling for Canadian Sleepers?

Both brands address Canada's variable climate with different cooling strategies to help you sleep cool.

Simba's Multi-Layered Cooling:

• Graphite-infused Simbatex foam conducts body heat away
• An open-cell structure increases airflow through comfort layers
• Aerocoil springs create active ventilation as they compress and expand
• Independent tests show better-than-average cooling performance.

Casper's Breathable Design:

• Breathe Flex foam features thousands of perforations for air circulation
• Open-cell construction prevents heat buildup
• Premium Snow collection offers advanced Phase Change Materials and Heat Delete Bands
• Standard models provide a good score, but not exceptional cooling

For hot sleepers on a budget, Simba's hybrid construction provides better natural cooling. For those willing to invest more, Casper's Snow collection, featuring specialized cooling technologies, outperforms both standard models.

How Do Simba and Casper Compare in Edge Support & Pressure Relief?

Edge Support Comparison:

• Simba: (Strong edge support) - Perimeter support foam reinforces edges
• Casper: (Average for all foam beds) - Standard for all-foam construction

Simba's superior edge support means couples can use the entire sleeping surface without roll-off. Casper's average edge support is functional but may compress noticeably when sitting on the mattress edge.

Pressure Relief Performance:

• Simba: Good for back/stomach sleepers, moderate for side sleepers
• Casper: Excellent for side sleepers, good for other positions

Casper’s memory foam and zoned support system excel at relieving pressure points, especially around the shoulders and hips, promoting balanced comfort for most sleepers. Simba's firmer surface provides excellent spinal alignment but less cushioning at pressure points.

What Is the Unboxing and Off-Gassing Experience Like?

Both mattresses arrive compressed in boxes, though Simba's packages are notably larger due to the spring layer, which doesn't compress as efficiently as pure foam.

Simba Unboxing:

• Heavier boxes due to spring content
• Moderate off-gassing that dissipates within 2-3 days
• Mattresses fully expand within 24-48 hours
• Handles are included on larger sizes to make the mattress easier to position

Casper Unboxing:

• Standard compressed packaging
• Minimal off-gassing lasting 2-4 days
• Quick expansion within hours
• No built-in handles

Both use CertiPUR-certified foams with low VOC emissions, ensuring safe indoor air quality during the break-in period.

Which Mattress Lasts Longer?

Durability depends on construction quality and usage patterns. Simba's hybrid design with individually pocketed coils typically provides longer structural life than all-foam mattresses. The steel springs resist permanent compression better than foam alone.

However, Casper uses high-density support foam engineered for decade-long performance. The company specifically designs the Casper Core to maintain structural integrity throughout the warranty period.

Both offer 10-year warranties, suggesting similar confidence in longevity. Real-world durability will depend on sleeper weight, usage patterns, and maintenance practices like regular rotation.

Which Mattress Offers Better Value for Money?

• Simba: Premium pricing (C$1,699-1,799) justified by hybrid construction, excellent edge support, and superior cooling. Good value for those prioritizing responsiveness and firmer support.
• Casper: Multiple price points from C$849 to C$999 offer options for budgets of all sizes. The One model offers solid performance at competitive pricing, while Snow collection delivers luxury features at premium rates.

For budget-conscious shoppers, Casper One provides better baseline value. For those wanting hybrid construction benefits, Simba offers competitive pricing compared to other hybrid mattresses.

On the other hand, Canadian shoppers should also consider our organic latex mattress collection for natural materials and locally crafted quality, or explore our hybrid mattresses for the best of both worlds.

Simba vs Casper: What Are Their Pros and Cons?

Simba Hybrid Original

Pros:

• Excellent edge support for full surface utilization
• Superior cooling through a multi-layered approach
• Responsive feels good for combination sleepers
• Hybrid construction offers traditional spring benefits
• Made in Canada supports local manufacturing

Cons:

• Higher price point limits accessibility
• Firm feel may not suit all side sleepers
• Limited model variety in the Canadian market
• A heavier weight makes moving difficult

Casper One

Pros:

• Competitive pricing for quality delivered
• Excellent pressure relief for side sleepers
• Good motion isolation for couples
• Multiple models across price ranges
• Established brand with proven track record

Cons:

• Average edge support affects usable surface
• All-foam construction may sleep warmer
• Less responsive feel than hybrid options
• Casper mattresses are made in the USA and shipped from Canadian warehouses.

FAQs

What is the Canadian version of Casper?

Casper operates directly in Canada through its Canadian website and retail partnerships with Sleep Country. The same models available in the US are offered to Canadian customers, with pricing in Canadian dollars and local customer service support. There isn't a separate "Canadian version"—you're getting the authentic experience with appropriate regional support.

What Are Some Canadian Alternatives to Simba and Casper?

Canadian shoppers have excellent domestic options, including Douglas (all-foam mattresses starting at C$799), Logan Cove (hybrid construction from C$999), and premium choices like Fawcett. Our natural latex mattresses offer superior durability and temperature regulation through 100% natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and New Zealand wool construction. These locally crafted options support Canadian manufacturing while often providing better value than imported brands.

Is the Simba Hybrid Better Than the Casper Hybrid?

Simba's micro-coil technology differs significantly from traditional pocketed coils in hybrid models. Simba uses 2,500 small conical springs for more granular body contouring, while other models employ full-height coils for traditional hybrid support. Simba generally offers firmer support and better edge stability, while other options provide more pressure relief and motion isolation. The "better" choice depends on your firmness preference and sleeping position needs.

What mattress is as good as Casper?

Several Canadian options match or exceed performance at competitive prices. Douglas provides excellent motion transfer reduction and value at C$799, while Logan Cove offers luxury hybrid construction starting at C$999.

For those seeking natural materials and superior craftsmanship, consider our Galiano natural latex mattress, which provides pressure relief through natural latex while maintaining excellent durability and temperature regulation through organic materials.

End Note

Choosing between Casper and Simba mattresses depends on your specific sleep needs and preferences. Simba excels for sleepers who prefer firmer support, want excellent edge support, and appreciate responsive hybrid construction. The superior cooling and Canadian manufacturing add value for many buyers, especially those choosing a queen size mattress for balanced comfort, medium plush feel, and space efficiency.

Other options shine for pressure-sensitive sleepers who need excellent pressure relief, particularly side sleepers. The top layer in many designs plays a key role in contouring comfort and airflow, while a high-quality mattress protector helps maintain hygiene and extend the mattress’s lifespan. The broader price range and multiple models provide options for various budgets and preferences.

However, Canadian shoppers should also explore locally crafted alternatives that offer superior materials and construction. Our mattress collection features natural, sustainable materials crafted on Vancouver Island with 10-year warranties and a 100-night comfort exchange. When you're ready to explore mattresses that combine the best of traditional craftsmanship with modern comfort, we're here to help you find your perfect sleep solution.

Citations:
[1] https://naplab.com/mattress-reviews/simba-hybrid-pro-review/
[2] https://casper.com/products/casper-one-foam
[3] https://simba.shop/pages/brand-comparison
[4] https://www.mattress-reviews.com/mattress-comparisons/casper-vs-simba-vs-douglas-mattress-review/
[5] https://en.sleepcountry.ca/brands/simba/