Endy vs Casper Mattress Comparison: Canadian Guide (Natural Alternative)

Choosing between Endy mattress and Casper mattress, two popular bed-in-a-box options in Canada, can be challenging. While both foam mattress brands promise quality and comfort, many Canadians are discovering there's a premium alternative worth considering. We'll examine how these mattress brands compare—and why Fawcett, with our crafted natural mattresses made in Victoria, BC, offers a sleep experience that synthetic alternatives simply can't match.

Quick Comparison Table: Endy vs Casper vs Fawcett

Need help selecting a mattress that's just right for you? Contact our sleep experts to receive personalized recommendations based on your comfort preferences and sleeping habits.

Mattress Overview & First Impressions

When it comes to profile and appearance, there are notable differences between these three mattresses. Endy mattress stands at 10 inches tall with a medium firmness profile, while Casper Original mattress is slightly taller at 11 inches with its zoned support layer.

Fawcett's superior offerings range from 7 to 13 inches, depending on the model, with Nootka and Cumberland hybrid options providing a more substantial profile. This additional mattress height isn't just for show—it accommodates our premium natural materials, which create a more luxurious sleep surface while delivering exceptional support.

The mattress cover materials also set these mattresses apart from one another. Endy features a machine washable cover made of polyester-spandex blend, and Casper mattress cover uses a non-removable recycled polyester requiring spot cleaning.

Fawcett elevates your sleep experience with certified organic cotton covers that naturally wick moisture and provide a cooler sleeping environment. Our breathable design works in conjunction with natural Joma wool comfort layers to create a naturally hypoallergenic sleep surface. From the moment you touch a Fawcett mattress, you'll feel the difference that premium natural materials make.

Construction Breakdown

Endy Mattress Layers

Endy's construction features three foam layers of synthetic materials:

• Top Layer: 2" proprietary Endy comfort foam with open cell foam structure
• Transition Layer: 3" polyurethane foam (1.8lbs/ft³ density)
• Support Layer: 5" high-density polyurethane foam (1.8lbs/ft³ density) support core

While CertiPUR-US certified to be free from certain chemicals, these materials remain synthetic in composition.

Casper Mattress Layers

Casper Original features a synthetic memory foam mattress design:

• Top Layer: 1.5" proprietary AirScape foam for cooling
• Middle Layer: 2" zoned memory foam (firmer under hips, softer under shoulders)
• Base Layer: 7" high-density support foams

Casper's primary innovation is their zoned support system, though still constructed from synthetic materials.

Fawcett's Premium Natural Construction

Fawcett mattresses represent a completely different approach to sleep technology, using materials that have stood the test of time:

• Organic Cotton Cover: Breathable, hypoallergenic
• Natural Joma Wool Comfort Layer: Temperature-regulating, moisture-wicking, and naturally fire-resistant without chemicals
• 100% Natural Talalay Latex: Responsive, breathable, and exceptionally durable
• Thoughtfully Engineered Support Systems:
• • Nootka: Zoned pocketed coils with latex reinforcement for targeted support
  • Cumberland: Dual coil system for enhanced contouring and our most luxurious feel

Unlike the synthetic materials in Endy and Casper, Fawcett's natural components are biodegradable, sustainable, and built to last decades—not years. Our mattresses aren't just better for your sleep; they're better for the planet, too.

Key Differences Between Mattress Types

Material Quality and Health Considerations

While Casper emphasizes engineering with their zoned support technology and Endy prioritizes consistency with their straightforward all foam mattress design, Fawcett takes a fundamentally different approach focused on natural wellness.

Our 100% natural Talalay latex offers inherent benefits that synthetic foams simply can't match:

• Exceptional durability: 20+ year lifespan compared to 7-10 years for synthetic foam
• Naturally cooler sleeping environment: Open cell structure that doesn't trap heat for hot sleepers
• No off-gassing: Sleep on your Fawcett mattress the first night without chemical odors
• Hypoallergenic properties: Resistant to dust mites and mold
• Biodegradable materials: Better for your home and the environment

These aren't marketing claims—they're the natural properties of the premium materials we've carefully selected for your best mattress experience.

Interested in comparing traditional foam mattresses to those made from premium natural materials? Visit our Victoria showroom or Nanaimo location to experience how our mattresses enhance comfort, support, and temperature control.

Firmness Options and Personalization

Endy offers a single medium-firm mattress option (6.5/10 on the mattress firmness scale) across their lineup, while Casper provides some variation across their models, but still with fixed foam firmness per model.

Fawcett stands apart with our customizable comfort approach. Our natural latex can be configured from soft (3/10) to extra-firm (9/10), with different configurations possible on each side of the mattress. This means you and your partner don't have to compromise on comfort—each of you can have your perfect firmness level in the same king-size mattress.

Temperature Regulation and Cooling

Sleeping hot is a common complaint with foam mattresses. Despite marketing claims about cooling technologies, both Endy and Casper mattresses use synthetic foams that inherently retain heat. Their structural modifications improve airflow somewhat, but many users still report overheating.

Fawcett achieves superior temperature regulation naturally through our thoughtfully selected materials:

• Joma Wool®: Naturally wicks moisture and helps you stay cool year-round
• Natural Talalay Latex: Features an open cell foam structure that allows for excellent air circulation
• Organic Cotton Cover: Breathable and designed to work with our natural filling materials

The result is a consistently comfortable sleep temperature regardless of the season—something our customers consistently highlight in their feedback.

Performance for Different Sleepers

Side Sleepers: While Endy provides decent pressure relief for average-weight side sleepers, Fawcett's Model 9 offers superior pressure point relief that gently cradles shoulders and hips without the "stuck" feeling of memory foam mattress designs. The natural buoyancy of our latex layers maintains spine neutrally aligned while relieving pressure points.

Back Sleepers: Casper's zoned support works well for back sleepers, but Fawcett's Model 7 combines zoned support with natural latex to create targeted extra lumbar support using premium natural materials. Many customers with chronic back pain and hip pain report significant improvement after switching to a Fawcett mattress.

Stomach Sleepers: Neither Endy nor Casper Original provide ideal firm support for stomach sleeping, especially for those over 170 lbs. Fawcett can be configured with firmer support to prevent the pelvic tilt that causes lower back strain during stomach sleeping—just another benefit of our customizable approach.

Combination Sleepers: Fawcett's natural latex offers superior responsiveness, instantly adapting to position changes without the lag time of memory foam. This makes our mattresses ideal for those who change sleeping position throughout the night.

Couples: With excellent motion isolation, customizable firmness on each side, and superior edge support, Fawcett mattresses are specifically designed to keep couples happy. No more compromising on comfort or experiencing motion transfer when your partner moves.

The True Cost of Your Mattress: Long-term Value

When considering initial cost, Endy ($895 CAD for Queen) and Casper Original ($1,295 CAD) may appear less expensive than Fawcett's Goldstream Hybrid natural mattresses ($1,399 for Queen). However, the true cost of a mattress must account for its lifespan:

• Endy and Casper: Typically last 7-10 years
• Fawcett: Natural latex constructions often exceed 15-20 years

This means that over two decades, you would need to replace a synthetic mattress at least twice, while your Fawcett mattress continues to provide consistent comfort and support. When factoring in longevity, a Fawcett mattress costs significantly less per year of use than conventional alternatives.

Add to this the health benefits of sleeping on natural, chemical-free materials night after night, and the value proposition becomes even clearer. Your mattress is one of the most important wellness investments you'll make—shouldn't it be made from the best materials possible?

Customer Experience & Policies

All three companies offer sleep trials, but Fawcett provides the longest comfort guarantee at 120 nights, acknowledging that natural materials sometimes require a brief adjustment period to reveal their full benefits.

Warranty coverage tells a similar story: Endy offers 15 years (with registration), Casper provides 10 years, and Fawcett stands behind our products with an industry-leading 20-year warranty, reflecting the inherent durability of our natural materials.

Unique to Fawcett is our Comfort Exchange Program, which allows customers to adjust the firmness of their mattress by exchanging individual layers rather than returning the entire product. This sustainable approach reduces waste while ensuring your complete satisfaction—just one example of our commitment to exceptional service.

Beyond Mattresses: Complete Your Sleep System

While comparing mattress options, consider that your sleep system works best when all components work together. Fawcett offers a complete range of natural sleep products that complement our mattresses:

• Organic Latex Pillows: The perfect companion to your natural latex mattress
• Organic Cotton Sheet Sets: Designed in Canada to enhance the breathability of your sleep system
• Natural Wool Bedding: Temperature-regulating duvets and toppers for year-round comfort
• Mattress Toppers: Add an extra layer of customized comfort to any mattress

By building a complete Fawcett sleep system, you'll maximize the benefits of our natural materials and experience sleep as it was meant to be—comfortable, restorative, and healthy.

If you're still comparing options, take a look at our Silk and Snow vs Douglas mattress review, a breakdown of the Thuma bed frame versus Silk and Snow, and a closer look at the Silk and Snow vs Casper mattress matchup.

FAQs

How do Endy vs Casper mattresses compare for seniors?

Senior sleepers often benefit from different mattress features than younger adults. While both Endy and Casper offer decent support, many senior sleepers find Casper's zoned support system provides better alignment for aging bodies. However, Fawcett's customizable firmness options prove most beneficial for seniors, as they can select the exact comfort level needed for their specific body shape and health concerns, with many configurations providing enhanced pressure point relief for arthritic joints.

Will my Endy or Casper mattress work with an adjustable bed frame?

Both Endy mattress and Casper Original mattress are compatible with adjustable bed frames. Their all foam beds construction allows them to flex without damage. Fawcett's natural latex mattresses also work exceptionally well with adjustable bases, with the added benefit of superior durability through repeated adjustments.

How do Endy and Casper compare to the Douglas mattress?

The Douglas mattress is another Canadian-made option that competes with Endy and Casper, offering a medium-firm feel similar to both the Endy and Casper mattresses. Like Endy, Douglas uses a washable cover, but incorporates cooling gel foam that Endy doesn't offer. While Douglas provides good value at a competitive price point, it still uses synthetic foam layers rather than the natural materials found in Fawcett mattresses.

Can I use Endy sheets with a Casper mattress?

Yes, Endy sheets are designed to fit most standard mattress sizes and will work with Casper mattresses. However, keep in mind that mattress height differences may affect the fit. Casper Original is 11" tall, while Endy is 10" tall, so Endy sheets should have sufficient pocket depth for either brand. Fawcett also offers premium organic cotton sheets designed to fit mattresses of various heights up to 16".

What's the difference between a rolled-up mattress and traditional delivery?

Both Endy and Casper arrive as rolled mattresses, compressed and packed in a box for convenient shipping and setup. This bed-in-a-box approach makes delivery easier, especially in apartments or homes with narrow stairways. Fawcett offers both compressed shipping and white-glove delivery service, where our team sets up your new mattress and removes packaging. The compression process doesn't affect the quality of any of these three mattresses, though natural latex will fully recover its shape faster than synthetic foams.

How does the Endy hybrid mattress compare to Casper's hybrid options?

The Endy hybrid mattress combines foam comfort layers with a pocketed coil support system, offering improved breathability and edge support compared to their all-foam model. Similarly, Casper Wave Hybrid enhances their design with premium coil systems. Both hybrid models provide better temperature regulation and support than their all-foam counterparts, though they still utilize synthetic materials. Fawcett's hybrid designs incorporate natural latex with pocketed coils, offering the responsiveness and durability of both materials without the drawbacks of synthetic foams.

The Natural Choice for Better Sleep

While Endy and Casper offer decent synthetic options for budget-conscious shoppers, Fawcett provides a premium natural alternative that delivers superior comfort, customization, and longevity. Our mattresses crafted in Victoria, BC represent the best of Canadian craftsmanship and a commitment to sleep health that synthetic brands can't match.

When comparing Endy vs Casper mattress options, many shoppers find themselves wondering if there's something better available. With customizable firmness, natural temperature regulation, exceptional durability, and our 100-night comfort guarantee, a Fawcett mattress isn't just a better night's sleep—it's a better approach to sleep for decades to come.

Contact our sleep experts today to discover the natural difference in a mattress made just for you.

A great sleep. A better you. Life changing.