Silk and Snow vs Douglas Mattress (Canadian Comparison)

Comparison at a Glance

Materials & Construction

Silk and Snow

Silk and Snow mattress features multiple layers totaling 10 inches:

• 2" high-density foam with cooling gel for pressure point relief
• 2" transition foam for support and reducing motion transfer
• 6" support foam as the bottom layer
• Antimicrobial mattress cover made from polyester blend

Douglas

Douglas mattress also uses foam layers at 10 inches total:

• 2" cooling gel foam (ecoLight with 40% less carbon input than traditional memory foam)
• 2" transition layer (Elastex foam as a latex alternative) for pressure relief
• 6" support foam for motion isolation
• Douglas mattress cover using CoolSense Infinitex fibres

Fawcett

Fawcett creates mattresses using premium natural materials:

• 100% Natural Talalay latex foam for resilient support and pressure points relief
• 100% Organic Cotton for a breathable sleep surface
• 100% Organic Joma Wool that doesn't retain heat
• Pocket coil system in our hybrid mattress models

Both Silk and Snow hybrid and Snow organic options are also available from Silk and Snow, while Douglas original remains their flagship model. Fawcett offers both all-latex mattress and hybrid mattress options for different preferences.

Firmness & Feel

The Silk and Snow mattress offers a softer mattress feel (3.7/10 firmness) with plush cushioning and contouring. According to third-party engineers, this softer mattress works well for side sleepers and lighter individuals but may lack proper spinal alignment for heavier sleepers.

The Douglas mattress provides a medium firm feel (6.7/10) with balanced support. Testing shows that this medium firm mattress accommodates multiple sleeping positions with excellent pressure relief. Many Douglas mattress review comments note how much movement is absorbed while maintaining proper spinal alignment.

Fawcett stands apart by offering customizable firmness options to match your specific needs. Whether you prefer a medium firm mattress or something softer, our mattresses are crafted with the perfect balance of comfort and support for your unique preferences. This personalization is especially valuable for couples with different firmness requirements in the same queen mattress.

Temperature Regulation & Cooling

Silk and Snow incorporates gel foam to help reduce how much heat the memory foam mattress retains, though the overall "hug" of the memory foam mattress may still be problematic for hot sleepers.

Douglas mattress features cooling gel foam and a moisture-wicking cover designed to create a cooler sleep surface than traditional memory foam mattresses. Their cooling gel technology helps hot sleepers rest more comfortably throughout the night.

Fawcett excels in natural temperature regulation without synthetic cooling gel. The breathable properties of natural latex foam, organic cotton, and Joma wool work together to help hot sleepers sleep soundly without overheating. These high-quality materials naturally dissipate moisture for comfort in all seasons.

Motion Isolation & Edge Support

Silk and Snow performs well in motion isolation (7.6/10) but rates lower in edge support (5.2/10) according to third-party engineers. This means light sleepers may still feel some motion transfer from restless partners.

Douglas offers excellent motion isolation (8.3/10) and above-average edge support for an all-foam mattress (7.8/10). This allows couples to sleep soundly without disturbing each other and use the entire sleep surface.

Fawcett mattresses provide superior motion isolation, especially in our all-latex models. The natural resilience of natural latex foam combined with individually wrapped coils creates a great mattress that absorbs movement while maintaining excellent edge support throughout the entire queen mattress or any size you choose.

Free Bundles & Accessories

Both online brands offer promotions with your mattress purchase:

Silk and Snow often includes a bedding bundle with their mattress purchase, including a mattress protector.

Douglas currently offers a free comfort sleep bundle with every Douglas mattress purchase, which includes pillows, sheets, and a mattress protector.

Fawcett focuses on creating the best mattress possible rather than including free bundles. However, we offer compatible bed frames and accessories designed to enhance the performance of our natural mattresses.

Health & Environmental Benefits

Silk and Snow uses CertiPUR-US certified foams with lower emissions than traditional memory foam. Their snow cover contains antimicrobial properties to help you sleep soundly.

Douglas emphasizes their eco-conscious foam with reduced carbon input and plant-derived cover fabric. Both companies ship to most locations except some remote regions.

Fawcett takes an entirely different approach, using only natural materials free from harmful chemicals. Our mattresses contain no synthetic foams that off-gas, making them ideal for health-conscious consumers who prioritize wellness.

Trial Period & Warranty

Silk and Snow offers a 365-night sleep trial and a 15-year warranty, with shipping throughout most of Canada.

Douglas provides a 365-night sleep trial and a 20-year warranty, also serving most Canadian locations outside remote regions.

Fawcett includes a 100-night comfort trial and a 10-year warranty. While our trial period is shorter, we provide personalized consultations to ensure you get the right mattress from the start.

Price Comparison

When comparing queen mattress prices:

• Silk & Snow: $800
• Douglas: $799
• Fawcett: Starting at $1,399

While Fawcett mattresses come at a slightly higher price point, they represent a worthwhile mattress purchase for those seeking natural materials and personalized comfort that alternative duvets and toppers cannot provide with synthetic mattresses.

Who Should Choose Each Mattress?

Choose Silk & Snow if you:

• Want a softer mattress with more "hug"
• Are primarily side sleepers or light sleepers
• Prefer the feel of a memory foam mattress
• Are comparing silk snow vs other budget-friendly options

Choose Douglas if you:

• Prefer a medium firm mattress with balanced support
• Want an eco-conscious foam mattress with a long warranty
• Are considering Douglas vs Silk and Snow based on motion isolation
• Want a free comfort sleep bundle with your purchase

Choose Fawcett if you:

• Value natural, chemical-free materials for healthier sleep
• Are hot sleepers seeking better temperature regulation
• Want customized firmness for your specific sleeping positions
• Prefer natural latex foam over memory foam
• Have allergies or sensitivities to synthetic materials
• Want to support Canadian craftsmanship

For more comparisons, check out how the Thuma bed compares to Silk and Snow, see our full Silk and Snow vs Casper review, or explore the key differences in our Endy vs Casper mattress comparison.

FAQs

Which is better for side sleepers: silk snow vs douglas?

Side sleepers typically need more pressure relief around shoulders and hips. The silk snow mattress offers a softer surface good for light sleepers, while douglas provides medium-firm support. Fawcett's customizable comfort layers create the perfect balance for any sleeping positions.

How do these mattresses compare for hot sleepers?

Fawcett mattresses provide superior cooling without synthetic cooling gel, using naturally breathable latex foam, organic cotton, and wool that doesn't retain heat. Douglas's cooling gel technology offers good temperature control for a foam mattress, while silk and snow may sleep somewhat warmer despite its gel foam layer.

Do memory foam mattresses contain harmful chemicals?

Both silk snow and douglas use CertiPUR-US certified foams with reduced emissions. However, Fawcett mattresses contain no synthetic foams or chemical adhesives whatsoever, making them the healthiest option for those with sensitivities.

Which Canadian mattress offers the best value?

While Silk and Snow vs Douglas represent lower initial prices, Fawcett provides superior long-term value through extended durability and natural health benefits. When comparing the best mattress options, consider both immediate comfort and long-term performance.

Final Thoughts: Why Consider Fawcett Mattress

While Silk and Snow and Douglas offer quality Canadian mattresses at accessible price points, Fawcett provides a natural alternative with personalized comfort. Our handcrafted mattresses use 100% natural materials that outperform synthetic options in longevity, temperature regulation, and health benefits. Natural Talalay latex maintains its supportive properties significantly longer than memory foam, offering better long-term value.

Ready for the best sleep of your life? Shop our natural mattress collection today or visit our Victoria or Nanaimo showroom to experience the Fawcett difference firsthand.

A great sleep. A better you. Life changing.

The Author: Duane Franklin

Co-Founder

A mattress maker since the age of 18, Duane honed his skills under the guidance of a master craftsman and gradually earned a reputation as Victoria's premier mattress maker. Through his experience and direct engagement with customers, he arrived at a valuable understanding of the perfect materials and methods for mattress making. Soon after, he met Ross and Fawcett Mattress was born.