Purple vs Casper Mattress: Canadian Sleeper's Guide (With an Alternative)

If you're comparing Purple mattress vs Casper, you're navigating two popular options with different approaches to sleep technology. Both brands promise better rest, but as a Canadian, you've got additional considerations like availability, shipping costs, and whether there's a better local option.

We've created this comparison to help you understand the key differences between these popular American brands while introducing Fawcett Mattress—a Canadian-made alternative that might better suit your specific sleep needs.

Quick Comparison: At a Glance

Having trouble deciding on the perfect mattress for your sleep style? Reach out to our sleep specialists for customized guidance tailored to your individual needs.

Company Background

Purple

Founded in 2015 by the Pearce brothers, Purple revolutionized the mattress industry with their proprietary GelFlex Grid technology. Based in Utah, they manufacture their Purple mattress products in the USA and distribute in Canada through both direct online sales and Sleep Country stores.

Purple offers a 100-night sleep trial and a 10-year warranty. Their mattresses are engineered with synthetic materials designed for deep pressure relief and cooling to prevent aches and pains.

Casper

Launched in 2014, Casper pioneered the direct-to-consumer bed in a box movement. While headquartered in New York, Casper mattress products are manufactured in the USA using globally sourced materials. Their products feature zoned support memory foam designed to provide targeted support for your lower back.

Casper offers a 100-night trial period, a 10-year warranty, and ships directly to Canadians with free shipping.

Fawcett

Founded in 2014 on Vancouver Island, Fawcett combines more than a decade of mattress expertise with a commitment to natural materials. We handcraft our mattresses locally in Victoria, BC, using 100% natural Talalay latex, organic cotton, and Joma Wool® from New Zealand.

We offer a 100-day comfort exchange program and a 10-year warranty. Rather than returns, we work with you to adjust your mattress to achieve your perfect mattress comfort and support.

Detailed Product Comparison

Materials

The most significant difference between Casper and Purple mattresses lies in their materials:

Purple uses:

• Proprietary GelFlex Grid material (hyper elastic polymer) for the Purple grid
• Transition layer of responsive comfort foam
• Dense support foam base layer
• Synthetic cover materials

Casper uses:

• Memory foam with zoned support system
• Balanced foam feel with softer foam for shoulders
• Firmer foam for lower back support
• Recycled polyester cover materials

Fawcett uses:

• 100% Natural Talalay latex (made from Hevea Brasiliensis tree sap)
• Organic cotton with Oeko-Tex® certification
• 100% Organic Joma Wool®
• Recycled steel in pocket coil springs (hybrid mattresses)

The natural materials in our Fawcett mattresses offer several key advantages:

• They don't off-gas or contain harmful chemicals
• Superior support and pressure relief
• They naturally regulate temperature without synthetic solutions
• They're more sustainable and environmentally friendly
• They're typically more durable, offering better long-term value

Construction

Purple's Construction:

• Top layer: 2" proprietary GelFlex Grid for good pressure relief
• Middle layer: Responsive comfort layer for transition
• Base layer: Dense support foam for durability
• Purple Hybrid versions add pocketed coils for better edge support

Casper's Construction:

• Top layer: AirScape perforated foam for temperature regulation
• Middle layer: Zoned support memory foam (softer foam at shoulders, firmer foam at hips)
• Base layer: High-density support foam
• Both the Casper Nova Hybrid and Casper Wave Hybrid incorporate pocket coils

Fawcett's Construction:

• Top layer: Natural Joma Wool® and organic cotton cover
• Comfort layer: 100% Natural Talalay latex (customizable firmness)
• Support layers: Either additional latex or pocket coil springs
• All materials are non-toxic and naturally fire-resistant without chemical treatments

Firmness Options

Purple offers:

• Original: Medium firm feel (6-7/10)
• Purple Plus: Medium (5-6/10)
• Purple Restore: Medium to Medium-firm (6/10)

Casper offers:

• Original all foam mattress: Medium-firm (6/10)
• Casper Nova Hybrid: Medium (5/10)
• Casper Wave Hybrid: Medium-soft (4/10)
• Snow Mattress: Medium-firm (6/10)
• Snow Hybrid: Medium-firm (6/10)

Fawcett offers:

• Fully customizable firmness from soft (3/10) to extra firm (9/10)
• Split king and dual-firmness options for couples with different sleeping positions
• Ability to adjust firmness during the 100-day comfort exchange period

Wondering if a mattress made from natural materials feels better than foam? Come experience the difference at our showrooms in Victoria or Nanaimo, and discover superior comfort, support, and breathability.

Sleep Experience Factors

Temperature Regulation

Purple approaches cooling through its Purple grid design, creating 1,400+ air channels that allow significant airflow. The hyper elastic polymer material doesn't retain heat like foam, making it an excellent choice for hot sleepers concerned about sleeping hot.

Casper uses perforated AirScape foam to improve breathability, but as a foam mattress, it can still retain some heat for very hot sleepers or in warmer climates.

Fawcett achieves temperature regulation naturally. The Joma Wool® layer wicks away moisture and regulates temperature year-round, while natural Talalay latex has an open-cell structure that allows for excellent air circulation. You'll stay cool in summer and warm in winter without synthetic cooling technologies.

Motion Isolation

Purple provides good motion isolation, though the responsive nature of the grid means some movement can transfer between partners who move around at night.

Casper excels at motion isolation due to its memory foam construction, making it a good choice for light sleepers with restless partners.

Fawcett's pocket coil hybrid options offer excellent motion isolation, while our all-latex models still perform well thanks to the natural properties of Talalay latex. Our dual-firmness options further enhance comfort for couples with different preferences.

Edge Support

Purple's basic models show moderate edge compression, while their Purple Hybrid models offer reinforced edges for better edge support.

Casper's all-foam models have weaker edge support, with some improvement in the Casper Wave Hybrid and Nova Hybrid versions.

Fawcett incorporates reinforced perimeters in all models, with additional edge support systems in our hybrid mattresses. This allows full use of the sleep surface and makes getting in and out of bed easier.

Ideal Sleeper Analysis

Side Sleepers

Purple excels for side sleepers under 230 lbs of body weight, as the grid collapses precisely under shoulders and hips for relieving pressure points and preventing joint pain.

Casper's zoned support provides strategic softness under shoulders but may not offer enough pressure relief for some side sleepers with specific needs.

Fawcett's customizable approach allows us to create the ideal surface for side sleepers of any body weight. Our natural latex immediately responds to pressure points while maintaining proper spinal alignment.

Back Sleepers

Purple offers medium-firm support that works well for most back sleepers, maintaining proper lower back support.

Casper's zoned design provides extra firmness under the hips, which is beneficial for back sleepers who need lumbar support to prevent aches and pains.

Fawcett can customize support zones specifically for back sleepers, with targeted reinforcement in the lumbar region to maintain proper spinal alignment while offering comfort.

Stomach Sleepers

Purple may not provide sufficient hip support for strict stomach sleepers over 170 lbs, potentially allowing the midsection to sink too deeply.

Casper works for lightweight stomach sleepers but may allow hip sinking for heavier individuals.

Fawcett offers firm configuration options specifically designed to prevent pelvic tilt for stomach sleepers, keeping the spine properly aligned throughout the night.

Customer Experience

Delivery and Setup

Purple mattresses are available through direct online ordering with free shipping to Canada, as well as through Sleep Country locations throughout the country.

Casper offers free shipping throughout Canada with bed-in-a-box delivery directly to your home.

Fawcett provides white-glove delivery service in Victoria and surrounding areas. For the rest of Canada, we offer carefully packaged shipping with detailed setup instructions. Our natural materials don't require the off-gassing period that synthetic mattresses need.

Sleep Trial and Returns

Purple offers a 100-night sleep trial with a 21-day minimum before returns. Returns are free with coordinated pickup.

Casper provides a 100-night trial with a 30-day minimum. Returns are free.

Fawcett takes a different approach with our 100-day comfort exchange program. Rather than returning a mattress that's not quite right, we work with you to make sure we adjust the firmness and comfort to meet your specific needs for a small fee (depending on your location). This reflects our custom-built approach and commitment to finding your perfect mattress.

Warranty

All three brands offer 10-year warranty protection, but the specifics differ:

Purple covers manufacturing defects and sagging greater than 1".

Casper covers deterioration with visible indentations greater than 1".

Fawcett's warranty covers manufacturing defects and body impressions greater than 1". Additionally, we offer ongoing support for comfort adjustments even beyond the initial exchange period (though additional fees may apply).

Price Comparison

When comparing the value of these mattresses, it's important to consider both initial cost and long-term durability:

While Fawcett mattresses have a higher initial price point, their natural latex construction typically lasts 15-20 years—approximately twice as long as the typical foam mattress. This extended lifespan can translate to better value over time, with fewer replacements needed.

Mattress Buying Guide: Finding Your Perfect Match

When shopping for a mattress, consider these key factors:

1. Identify Your Sleeping Positions: Side sleepers need softer surfaces for shoulder and hip pressure relief, back sleepers benefit from medium firm support, and stomach sleepers require firmer surfaces to prevent pelvic tilt.
2. Preferred Feel: Do you want the slow-conforming "hug" of memory foam (Casper), the unique responsive feel of a hyper elastic polymer grid (Purple), or the naturally responsive support of latex (Fawcett)?
3. Temperature Concerns: Hot sleepers should consider Purple's grid system or Fawcett's naturally breathable latex, while Casper's foam may retain more heat despite cooling technologies.
4. Support Needs: All three brands offer good support, but Fawcett's customizable approach allows for targeted reinforcement where you need it most.

You may also find value in our Endy vs Casper mattress comparison, an in-depth Nectar vs Purple mattress review, and our guide to the Novaform vs Casper mattress differences.

FAQs

Which is the best mattress, Casper vs Purple?

The best mattress between Casper vs Purple depends on your specific needs. If you value a unique, responsive feel with excellent cooling, Purple might be better, especially for hot sleepers. If you prefer traditional memory foam contouring and zoned support, Casper could be a better choice, ideal for combination sleepers needing minimal motion transfer. Both offer a 100-night sleep trial and 10-year warranties, available in Canada through their respective sales channels.

What mattress is better than Purple?

Many mattresses are considered good alternatives in a Purple mattress comparison, depending on your preferences. For those seeking a natural, customizable option, Fawcett Mattress stands out with its 100% natural Talalay latex and organic materials, offering superior breathability and durability. Other options like Saatva or Nectar might also suit, but Fawcett's Canadian-made, non-toxic approach is ideal for health-conscious buyers who want a mattress that will last significantly longer than synthetic alternatives.

Is Purple the same as Casper?

No, Casper and Purple mattresses come from different companies with distinct technologies. Purple uses proprietary GelFlex Grid for a responsive, floating feel, while Casper uses zoned support memory foam for conforming support. They cater to different sleep preferences, with Purple focusing on cooling and Casper on motion isolation. Fawcett takes yet another approach with natural materials that offer both cooling properties and customizable support.

Do hospitals use Purple mattresses?

Generally, hospitals do not use Purple mattresses, as they are consumer-grade products designed for home use. Hospitals typically use medical-grade mattresses specifically designed to prevent bedsores and meet stringent hygiene standards. According to certified sleep science coach experts with hands-on testing experience, these specialized mattresses have different requirements than the typical consumer mattress.

Which Mattress Is Right for You?

Choosing the right mattress ultimately depends on your priorities. Purple is ideal for sleepers who prefer advanced cooling and unique pressure relief, while Casper fits those seeking traditional memory foam comfort at an accessible price.

While our Fawcett mattresses may have a higher initial price than some mass-produced options, the combination of premium natural materials, customizable comfort, and Canadian craftsmanship offers exceptional value and durability. Our mattresses are designed to provide years of healthy, comfortable sleep without the chemical off-gassing or premature sagging common in synthetic mattresses.

We invite you to explore our handcrafted mattress collection or speak with one of our sleep experts to discover how natural materials and personalized support can transform your sleep experience.

A great sleep. A better you. Life changing.