Silk and Snow vs Casper Mattress Comparison (With a Natural Alternative)

Choosing the right mattress isn't just about buying a piece of furniture—it's investing in your health and wellbeing. With Canadians spending nearly a third of our lives sleeping, finding that perfect balance of comfort, support, and value matters more than ever.

If you're researching mattress options, you've likely encountered Silk and Snow vs Casper—two popular Canadian choices that have revolutionized how we shop for sleep solutions. But what if you're looking for something beyond the standard foam mattress options? Something truly natural and customizable?

This mattress review compares these popular brands while introducing a compelling natural alternative that might just transform your sleep experience, addressing everything from edge support to pressure point relief for different sleeping positions.

Quick Comparison: At a Glance

Unsure which mattress best suits your individual sleep needs? Connect with our sleep experts for personalized recommendations tailored specifically to your sleeping style and preferences.

Silk and Snow: Canadian-Made Value

What They're Known For

Founded in 2017, Silk and Snow has built a strong reputation for transparency and value. Their "Made in Canada" approach resonates with consumers seeking to support local businesses while getting excellent quality at accessible prices. Silk and Snow offers exceptional motion transfer reduction, making their mattresses ideal for light sleepers.

Their Mattress Lineup

Silk and Snow offers three primary models:

• The S&S Mattress (All-Foam): Their flagship uses premium high-density gel memory foam (2.5 lb gel-infused) for cooling and pressure relief. Available in medium firm and firm options with an antimicrobial silver-infused mattress cover.
• The Silk and Snow Hybrid Mattress: Combines a memory foam comfort layer with pocketed coils in the support layer for enhanced edge support, better heat dissipation, and reduced motion transfer.
• The S&S Organic: Features GOTS-certified organic cotton, GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex, and a pocketed coil support system for proper spinal alignment.

Who They're Best For

Silk and Snow mattresses are ideal for:

• Value-conscious shoppers seeking quality foam mattress materials
• Side sleepers needing pressure point relief
• Couples who prioritize motion isolation
• Canadians who prefer supporting local manufacturing over options from Sleep Country

Casper: Technology-Driven Innovation

What They're Known For

Since 2014, Casper has built its brand on sleep technology innovation, backed by research from their "Casper Labs." While not originally Canadian, they've established a strong presence in our market with localized pricing and physical retail locations like Sleep Country.

Their Mattress Lineup

Casper's Canadian lineup includes:

• The Casper Original: Their flagship all-foam mattress with AirScape cooling layer in the top layer and balanced medium firm feel.
• Original Hybrid: This is an enhanced support version that combines AirScape foam upper layers and pocketed coils with a zoned support system for ergonomic spinal alignment.
• Snow Models: Premium cooling options with HeatDelete bands that dissipate body heat and phase change materials for temperature regulation. The Casper Snow mattress and Snow Hybrid mattress are specifically designed for hot sleepers who struggle with heat retention.

Who They're Best For

Casper mattresses work well for:

• Hot sleepers who prioritize cooling gel technology and heat dissipation
• Back and combination sleeping positions
• Those who want in-person testing options before committing to a new mattress
• Technology enthusiasts who appreciate innovative design and foam encasement for good edge support

Curious about how foam mattresses measure up against natural alternatives? Visit our Victoria or Nanaimo showrooms to feel the difference in comfort, support, and temperature regulation firsthand.

Fawcett: The Natural Alternative

What Makes Us Different

While Silk and Snow and Casper have their strengths, Fawcett Mattress takes a fundamentally different approach. As Vancouver Island's own mattress manufacturer, we make each mattress in Victoria, BC, using natural materials and traditional techniques that prioritize health, sustainability, and personalization.

We're not just another mattress company—we're artisans dedicated to creating the healthiest sleep environment possible without compromising on comfort or support.

Our Natural Materials Advantage

Unlike both competitors, we use exclusively natural components:

• 100% Natural Talalay Latex cores (no synthetic foams or foam layer construction)
• 100% Organic cotton quilted cover
• Joma wool fire barriers instead of chemical flame retardants
• 100% Natural Talalay Latex

These materials aren't just better for your health—they create a sleep experience that traditional memory foam simply can't match. Our latex provides responsive support that gently contours to your body while remaining cool and breathable throughout the night.

Personalization for Perfect Sleep

One of our most popular features—and something neither Silk and Snow nor Casper offers—is dual-sided customization. We can configure your mattress with different firmness levels on each side, making it ideal for couples with different preferences. No more compromise on comfort!

We offer fully customized comfort layers using natural Talalay latex in soft, medium, and firm configurations that can be arranged to suit your individual needs. It's not just a mattress; it's your mattress.

Head-to-Head Comparison

Material Quality & Sustainability

Silk and Snow uses dense, high-quality memory foam that exceeds industry standards. Their antimicrobial cover helps prevent bacterial growth, though it relies on silver-infused technology. The Silk Snow Hybrid offers a transition layer between the comfort layer and the firmer coils in the bottom layer.

Casper utilizes their proprietary AirScape foam with perforations for cooling. Their premium lines incorporate phase change materials and cooling gel layers to combat heat retention common in traditional memory foam.

Fawcett's Approach: We use 100% natural Talalay latex cores with no synthetic foams or chemical adhesives. Our construction includes organic cotton covers and Joma wool fire barriers instead of chemical treatments. For those concerned about off-gassing and long-term chemical exposure, our natural approach offers peace of mind that neither competitor can match.

Temperature Regulation

Silk and Snow uses gel-infused memory foam to mitigate heat retention. Their hybrid mattress offers better airflow through the coil layer, though extreme hot sleepers might find it insufficient despite the cooling gel.

Casper has made cooling a central feature, especially in their Snow models with HeatDelete bands and phase change materials designed specifically for how much movement and body heat affects sleep quality.

Fawcett's Approach: Rather than adding synthetic cooling technologies, we rely on the inherent properties of our materials. Talalay latex is naturally breathable with an open-cell structure that allows for superior airflow. Combined with moisture-wicking Joma wool, this creates naturally temperature-neutral sleep without chemical additives.

Durability and Value

Silk and Snow uses higher-density foams than many competitors, with a 15-year warranty that exceeds industry standards. Their foam mattress construction and foam encasement around pocketed coils in the Silk and Snow Hybrid provides good edge support and longevity.

Casper follows industry norms for expected lifespan with a standard 10-year warranty. Their mattress protector is recommended to extend the life of their products.

Fawcett's Approach: Natural Talalay latex is renowned for durability, often lasting 15-20 years without significant compression—approximately twice as long as memory foam. Our mattresses avoid the common breakdown issues associated with synthetic foams, potentially offering better value despite the higher initial investment.

Which Mattress is Right for You?

Choose Silk and Snow if:

• You're seeking excellent value with Canadian manufacturing
• Motion isolation is a top priority for light sleepers
• You prefer the deep pressure relief of memory foam for pressure points
• You're working with a tighter budget but still want quality comparable to the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Choose Casper if:

• You sleep extremely hot and need specialized cooling technology beyond what the Endy mattress or Endy comfort foam provides
• You prefer to try before you buy at a physical location
• You like the classic "hug" feeling of memory foam with proper spinal alignment
• You want a zoned support system for back pain relief

Choose Fawcett if:

• You value natural, non-toxic materials for healthier sleep
• You and your partner have different firmness preferences on the firmness scale
• You're concerned about chemical sensitivities or allergies
• You want a mattress crafted in BC that will last decades
• You prioritize environmental sustainability in your purchases
• You're looking for more support than different mattress options from traditional retailers provide

You might also be interested in our side-by-side analysis of Silk and Snow vs Endy mattress features, a deep dive into the Logan and Cove compared to Silk and Snow, and this detailed Purple vs Casper mattress breakdown.

FAQs

Are Silk and Snow mattresses of good quality?

Yes, Silk and Snow mattresses offer excellent value with high-quality materials at competitive prices. Their higher-density memory foam (2.5 lb vs. industry standard 1.8 lb) provides better durability and pressure point relief. With numerous positive reviews and a generous 365-night trial period, they've established a strong reputation for comfort and quality.

How does Casper compare to other mattress brands?

Casper competes well with innovative cooling technology and zoned support systems. Silk and Snow provides similar pressure relief at a lower price point, while Fawcett offers a natural alternative using latex instead of memory foam, with customization options Casper doesn't provide. For those seeking Casper's cooling technology, the Silk and Snow Hybrid offers similar temperature regulation at a more accessible price.

What's the difference between memory foam and latex mattresses?

Memory foam (used by Silk and Snow and Casper) contours closely to the body, slowly adapting to pressure and heat. It excels in pressure relief and motion isolation but may sleep warm and create a "hugging" sensation. Latex (used by Fawcett) provides more responsive support with a buoyant feel. It sleeps naturally cooler, responds immediately to movement, and typically lasts longer. Memory foam is petroleum-based with potential off-gassing, while natural latex is derived from rubber trees without synthetic additives.

Can mattresses help with back pain?

Yes, the right mattress can significantly help with back pain by providing proper support and alignment. Medium firm mattresses (like Silk and Snow Original, Casper Original, or Fawcett's medium configuration) generally work best for back pain sufferers. Zoned support systems provide targeted lumbar support, while latex mattresses offer responsive support that maintains spinal alignment while being more resilient than memory foam. Heavier sleepers may need firmer coils or denser foam for adequate support.

What's the advantage of buying from a Canadian mattress company?

Buying from Canadian mattress companies like Fawcett Mattress offers several advantages: supporting Canadian jobs, reducing carbon footprint from shipping, compliance with domestic safety regulations, more accessible customer service, easier warranty processing, and products designed specifically for Canadian preferences and climate. Supporting local businesses strengthens our economy and promotes sustainable manufacturing practices.

How important are mattress certifications?

Mattress certifications provide assurance about safety and quality. CertiPUR-US (held by Silk and Snow and Casper) certifies that foams are made without certain harmful chemicals and have low VOC emissions. This addresses basic safety concerns but doesn't eliminate all chemicals. GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) and GOLS (Global Organic Latex Standard) certifications (held by Fawcett) are more stringent, ensuring materials are truly organic with strict environmental and social criteria throughout production.

What should I know about mattress off-gassing?

Off-gassing refers to the release of chemicals from new mattresses, particularly those made with synthetic foams. Memory foam mattresses typically emit a "new mattress smell" from VOCs released as the mattress decompresses. While most manufacturers use certified foams with reduced VOC levels, some sensitive individuals may experience headaches or respiratory irritation. Natural latex mattresses like Fawcett's produce minimal off-gassing, as they contain few to no synthetic materials, making them preferable for those with chemical sensitivities.

Experience the Fawcett Difference

While Silk and Snow and Casper both produce quality mattresses with distinct advantages, we offer something fundamentally different—a handcrafted, customizable, natural sleep solution that addresses health concerns while providing exceptional comfort.

Our mattresses aren't compressed in boxes because we believe natural materials deserve better treatment. Each one is delivered flat, maintaining the integrity of the materials inside, and ready to use with any queen-size bed frame.

Explore our natural mattress collection or speak with a sleep expert today to start your journey toward better sleep.

A great sleep. A better you. Life changing.