Big Fig vs Logan and Cove Mattress (Canada): Full Guide

Choosing the right mattress in Canada means navigating countless options, but two brands consistently rise to the top of hybrid mattresses conversations: Big Fig and Logan and Cove. Whether you're seeking specialized support for heavier bodies or versatile comfort for all sleep styles, understanding the key differences between these premium mattresses helps ensure you make the mattress purchase that transforms your sleep quality. Both brands offer exceptional construction and customer service, yet they serve distinctly different needs within the canadian mattress market.

Key Takeaways

• Big Fig specializes in plus-size support with a 1,100-pound weight capacity and a lifetime warranty, while Logan and Cove emphasize versatility across all sleeper types with three distinct models.
• Logan and Cove mattress offers superior Canadian value starting at C$999 with a 365-night sleep trial, compared to Big Fig's $1,699 USD pricing and 120-night sleep trial.
• Both brands feature advanced cooling features—Big Fig's THERMOGEL and Logan and Cove's gel-infused foam—with comparable temperature regulation performance.
• Manufacturing location affects delivery—Logan and Cove mattresses arrive faster in Canada (5-10 days) than Big Fig's 2-3 weeks from Ohio.
• Choose Big Fig for heavyweight sleepers (230+ lbs) who require maximum durability; choose Logan and Cove Choice for most Canadian sleepers seeking excellent hybrid mattress performance and value.

Big Fig vs Logan and Cove Mattress Comparison Table Overview

What is the Big Fig Mattress Best Known For?

Big Fig earned its reputation as the premier mattress for plus-size sleepers through specialized engineering that addresses challenges that traditional innerspring mattresses cannot. The Cleveland-manufactured luxury hybrid mattress features 50% more individually wrapped pocket coils than typical premium hybrid mattresses—approximately 1,600 pocketed coils in a queen size—combined with high-density foam layers specifically formulated to resist compression under substantial weight loads.

The brand's commitment extends beyond physical construction to representation and inclusivity. Big Fig explicitly states that "everybody has a right to life, love, representation, and a good night's sleep," reflecting their founding philosophy that the mattress industry had overlooked heavier individuals who needed enhanced support, superior edge support, and materials engineered to prevent sagging.

What Makes Logan & Cove Stand Out in Canada?

Logan and Cove represent Canada's approach to hybrid mattresses excellence through domestic manufacturing, exceptional value, and comprehensive customer protection.

Their three-tier model strategy addresses different comfort needs without overwhelming consumers with choices. The Logan and Cove Choice provides entry-level luxury, the Logan and Cove Frontier adds micro-coil technology for enhanced comfort, and all models feature zoned support systems that provide targeted reinforcement where the body needs it most.

What truly distinguishes the Cove mattress is its 365-night sleep trial—a full year to evaluate your new mattress through seasonal changes, life transitions, and extended real-world testing.

How Do Logan and Cove Mattress Compare to Big Fig?

Mattress Construction and Materials

Big Fig employs a heavyweight-focused hybrid construction with a perforated, gel-infused foam comfort layer, three distinct high-density foam layers (1.8-2.5 PCF density), and 15-gauge steel support coils for maximum durability. The 80 ILD reinforced edge support provides strengthened perimeter support, allowing comfortable sitting without compression.

Logan and Cove take a different approach with their Choice model, featuring gel foam comfort layers and proprietary Elastex foam designed for responsiveness without memory foam's "stuck" sensation. The Frontier adds a dedicated micro coil layer beneath the comfort zone, creating a coil-on-coil design that enhances pressure relief and motion isolation.

Both brands prioritize CertiPUR-US-certified foam layers, ensuring the materials meet strict health and environmental standards. However, Big Fig's cooling gel-infused foam offers inherent breathability and responsiveness. In contrast, Logan and Cove's synthetic foam formulations focus on value and consistency across their medium-firm hybrid mattress options.

Cooling Features and Temperature Control

Temperature regulation represents a strength for both brands, though they achieve cooling through different technologies. Big Fig's THERMOGEL COOLING® treatment activates when exposed to body moisture, creating an immediate cooling effect that independent testing shows reduces surface temperatures by approximately 9-10 degrees for those who sleep hot.

Logan and Cove mattress incorporates gel foam throughout their comfort layers and leverage their hybrid construction's natural air circulation. The individually wrapped pocket coils create air channels that prevent heat buildup, while the Frontier's micro coils layer adds additional breathability pathways through breathable hollow fibre fill.

Edge Support and Pressure Relief

Strong edge support showcases Big Fig's engineering focus, earning a perfect 10/10 in independent testing. The reinforced 80 ILD foam encasement and strategic coil placement at the perimeter prevent the sinking sensation common in standard mattresses, making it easier to sit on the bed's edge and maximizing usable sleeping surface.

The Logan and Cove Choice achieves exceptional edge support of 9.4 out of 10 through foam encasement and perimeter coil reinforcement. At the same time, the Frontier's plush Euro-top slightly reduces edge stability to 7.3 out of 10—still above average but noticeably softer at the perimeter than a firmer mattress.

For pressure-point relief, Logan and Cove excels with a 9.0 out of 10 across its models, while Big Fig achieves similar ratings with less sinkage (1.49 inches versus Logan and Cove's 2.4 inches). This difference makes Logan and Cove better for side sleepers who need deeper contouring at pressure points, while Big Fig suits sleepers who prefer to feel supported "on top" of the mattress.

Motion Isolation and Motion Transfer

Big Fig demonstrates exceptional motion isolation despite its responsive feel, earning a perfect 10 out of 10 scores through careful engineering of individual coil wrapping and foam layering. Couples experience minimal sleep disturbance from partner motion transfer, though the mattress's high bounce (11 inches of rebound) creates noticeable responsiveness during intimate activity.

Logan and Cove show moderate motion transfer, with the Choice scoring 7.2 out of 10 and the Frontier at 7.4 out of 10. The breathable pocket coil design provides superior motion isolation compared to traditional innerspring mattresses. However, it doesn't match Big Fig's specialized engineering or the comprehensive motion-damping of memory foam mattress alternatives.

Firmness and Feel

Big Fig maintains a consistent medium-firm feel (6.5-7 on a 10-point scale) across its Classic model, with the Firm reaching 7-8 for maximum support and the Luxe offering slightly softer characteristics for side sleepers. The responsive latex and high-density foam create a supportive, low-sinkage feel.

Logan and Cove offer a wider range of firmness: the Choice delivers medium-firm support (6/10). At the same time, the Frontier's additional micro coils and Euro-top layers create a medium feel (5/10) with enhanced plushness compared to a firmer mattress. This difference makes the Frontier more suitable for side sleepers seeking pressure relief at pressure points.

Sleeping Position and Body Type

Big Fig excels for heavyweight sleepers (230+ pounds) across all sleeping positions, with the Classic particularly suitable for back sleepers and the Firm ideal for stomach sleepers who need maximum support. Side sleepers over 230 pounds find adequate comfort, though lighter side sleepers may experience the mattress as too firm.

Logan and Cove Choice serve average-weight sleepers (130-230 pounds) exceptionally well across all preferred sleeping positions. The Choice works for back, side, and lighter stomach sleepers. At the same time, the Frontier's enhanced comfort layers make it especially suitable for combination sleepers with pressure sensitivity who change sleeping position throughout the night.

Sleep Trial & Warranty

Big Fig offers a 120-night sleep trial and a lifetime warranty that covers manufacturing flaws, construction issues, and significant sagging over its 15–20-year lifespan. This reflects exceptional confidence in their specialized construction.

Logan and Cove mattress offers a remarkable 365-night sleep trial—allowing evaluation through seasonal changes and extended use—paired with a 15-year limited warranty that exceeds mattress industry standards. The extended sleep trial particularly benefits Canadian customers who are unsure about their firmness preferences or mattress compatibility.

Durability & Long-Term Performance

Big Fig's heavyweight engineering translates to exceptional durability, with materials specifically chosen to resist compression and maintain support under substantial loads. The lifetime warranty reflects genuine confidence that these mattresses will maintain their performance characteristics for 15-20 years with proper care and an appropriate mattress foundation.

Logan and Cove mattress has an expected lifespan of 7-10 years under normal use conditions, typical for a quality hybrid, but shorter than Big Fig's heavyweight-focused engineering. The 15-year warranty provides adequate protection during the mattress's productive lifespan.

Which Mattress Offers Better Pricing Value

Logan and Cove provide exceptional value for most Canadian consumers, with the Choice starting at C$999 and the Frontier at C$1,299—substantially less than Big Fig's $1,699 USD starting price when accounting for currency exchange. Logan and Cove frequently include their free comfort sleep bundle (pillows, mattress protector, sheets) worth C$500+, effectively reducing net acquisition costs for the new mattress purchase.

Big Fig's premium pricing reflects specialized engineering for heavyweight sleepers and a lifetime warranty. When amortized over their projected 15-20-year lifespan, the per-year cost becomes competitive with less durable alternatives that require more frequent replacement.

For average-body-weight Canadian sleepers, Logan and Cove offer superior value through comparable independent testing scores, extended sleep trials, and domestic manufacturing. For plus-size sleepers requiring specialized support, Big Fig's investment proves justified by unique capabilities unavailable elsewhere in the canadian mattress market.

What Are the Pros and Cons of Each Mattress?

Big Fig Advantages:

• Exceptional weight capacity (1,100 lbs) and heavyweight-focused engineering
• Perfect motion isolation and strong edge support scores
• Lifetime mattress warranty and proven 15-20 year durability
• Advanced THERMOGEL cooling gel foam technology for those who sleep hot

Big Fig Limitations:

• Premium pricing may exceed the budget for average body weight sleepers
• Longer shipping times to Canada when the mattress arrives (2-3 weeks)
• May feel too firm for lightweight side sleepers seeking a softer mattress
• Limited firmness options compared to Logan and Cove's variety

Logan and Cove Advantages:

• Outstanding value with Canadian manufacturing and fast delivery
• An extended 365-night sleep trial reduces the risk of a new mattress purchase risk
• Multiple models addressing different sleep styles and preferred sleeping positions
• Excellent pressure point relief for side sleepers and combination sleepers

Logan and Cove Limitations:

• Moderate motion transfer compared to Big Fig's isolation
• Shorter expected lifespan (7-10 years vs Big Fig's 15-20)
• Weight capacity limitations for heavyweight couples
• Euro-top models show poor edge support compared to firmer alternatives

How Do You Choose Which Mattress Is Best For You?

Your perfect mattress choice depends on body weight, sleeping position, and specific comfort priorities. Consider Big Fig if you weigh over 230 pounds, sleep with a partner of similar weight, prioritize maximum edge support and motion isolation, or value lifetime warranty protection. The specialized engineering justifies premium pricing for heavyweight sleepers who have struggled with the durability of traditional innerspring mattresses.

Choose Logan and Cove Choice if you weigh under 230 pounds, prefer side sleeping with enhanced pressure relief, value an extended sleep trial for purchase confidence, or prioritize Canadian-made products with fast domestic delivery. The exceptional value and versatile comfort make the Cove mattress ideal for most Canadian sleepers seeking the benefits of a hybrid mattress over an all-foam mattress.

For couples with mixed sleep styles, consider Logan and Cove's versatility and the ability to exchange models during the 365-night sleep trial. For couples where both partners weigh over 230 pounds, Big Fig's specialized engineering and weight capacity are essential compared to standard foam mattress options.

Consider exploring our natural latex mattresses for organic, sustainable alternatives crafted on Vancouver Island, or browse our hybrid mattress collection for Canadian-made options that emphasize natural materials and customization. Our collection includes bed frames and bedding options to complete your sleep setup.

Interested in more mattress matchups? Explore how value brands compare in our Novaform vs Douglas review, see how natural and synthetic materials stack up in GhostBed vs Silk & Snow Organic, or dive into premium comfort in our Tempur-Pedic vs Logan & Cove comparison.

FAQs

Are either of these mattresses good for back pain?

Both Big Fig and Logan and Cove can help with back pain, though they address different underlying causes. Big Fig excels for heavier individuals whose back pain stems from poor edge support or mattress sagging, providing firm, consistent spinal alignment with high-density materials and a robust pocketed coil system.

The Logan and Cove mattress helps relieve back pain caused by pressure points or sleeping position issues, offering balanced support with enough contouring to maintain natural spinal curves. For chronic back pain, consider our natural latex options, which provide responsive support while conforming to individual body shapes without the memory foam feel.

Which mattress is best for hot sleepers?

Both mattresses perform similarly in temperature regulation, earning identical 9.0 out of 10 cooling scores from NapLab testing. Big Fig's THERMOGEL COOLING® provides active temperature reduction when it comes into contact with body moisture. At the same time, Logan and Cove's hybrid construction and gel foam layers offer consistent breathability through air circulation.

Hot sleepers who sleep hot can choose based on other preferences, knowing that both provide excellent thermal management compared to a memory foam or all-foam mattress. Our organic cotton bedding complements any good mattress by enhancing breathability and moisture-wicking.

Conclusion

Both Big Fig and Logan and Cove represent premium hybrid mattress options, yet they serve distinctly different Canadian consumers. Big Fig delivers unmatched support and durability for heavyweight sleepers willing to invest in specialized engineering and lifetime protection. At the same time, Logan and Cove mattress provides exceptional value, versatility, and customer-friendly policies for the broader Canadian market.

The Logan and Cove Choice emerges as the superior choice for most Canadian consumers through competitive pricing, extended sleep trial periods, domestic manufacturing advantages, and excellent independent testing scores across all performance categories. For plus-size sleepers who require maximum weight capacity and specialized support, Big Fig's premium investment proves worthwhile compared to traditional innerspring mattresses or foam mattress alternatives.

Ready to experience the difference of truly crafted sleep? Explore our Canadian-made mattresses crafted on Vancouver Island using natural, sustainable materials, or discover our complete bedding collection to create your perfect sleep environment. With our 100-night comfort exchange and 10-year warranty, we're confident you'll discover the transformative power of quality, natural sleep materials that support your individual needs.

Citations:

[1] https://www.sleepadvisor.org/big-fig-mattress-review/
[2] https://sleepdoctor.com/pages/reviews/logan-and-cove-mattress-review
[3] https://naplab.com/mattress-reviews/big-fig-review/
[4] https://naplab.com/mattress-reviews/logan-and-cove-choice-review/
[5] https://www.sleepfoundation.org/mattress-reviews/big-fig-mattress-review