Logan and Cove vs Douglas Mattress (Canada): Ultimate Comparison for 2025

When shopping for a quality mattress in Canada, two names consistently stand out: Logan & Cove and Douglas. Both brands have earned loyal followings by delivering exceptional sleep experiences at accessible prices, but they take remarkably different approaches to mattress construction. If you're weighing these options for your new mattress purchase, you're likely wondering which will give you the best night's sleep for your investment.

Key Takeaways

• Douglas delivers superior motion isolation and costs $200 less at $799 CAD, making it ideal for couples and budget-conscious buyers.
• Logan & Cove provide exceptional edge support (9.5/10) and hybrid construction benefits through their pocketed coil system at $999 CAD.
• Both offer identical 365-night sleep trials and free Canadian shipping, with Douglas providing a 20-year warranty vs Logan & Cove's 15-year coverage.
• Motion isolation vs responsiveness represents the key trade-off: Douglas excels for light sleepers with restless partners, while Logan & Cove better serve combination sleepers.
• Your sleep position matters most: side sleepers benefit from either option, back sleepers can choose based on preference, and stomach sleepers should prefer Logan & Cove's firmer coil support.

Logan and Cove vs Douglas Mattress Side-by-Side Comparison

What is Logan & Cove?

Logan & Cove represents the luxury hybrid mattress option. Launched in 2018, this premium brand focuses on combining the pressure relief of foam layers with the traditional support and responsiveness of individually wrapped coils.

The company crafts its mattresses in Canadian facilities near Toronto, using materials such as gel-infused memory foam and high-count, pocketed steel coils. Logan & Cove has earned recognition as Canada's best mattress and Best Hybrid Mattress for 2025 from multiple review organizations.

With pricing starting at $799 for a queen-size mattress, the Choice model Logan & Cove positions itself as an accessible luxury option that bridges the gap between budget foam mattresses and premium retail offerings.

What is Douglas Mattress?

Douglas mattress emerged in 2017 as a Canadian-first mattress brand, founded by brothers Sam and Andy Prochazka, specifically to serve Canadian sleepers. The brand recognized that most bed-in-a-box companies designed their products primarily for American consumers, then adapted them for Canadian sale.

Douglas takes an all foam mattress approach, using three foam layers of proprietary polyurethane foam blends in a 10-inch profile. The company engineered its materials specifically for Canada's diverse climate, from humid Ontario summers to dry prairie winters.

Named Canada's best mattress for 2024, Douglas has sold over 150,000 mattresses across the country and accumulated more than 17,000 verified five-star reviews. At $799 for a queen-size, it's positioned as an exceptional value for those seeking a good night's sleep.

How Do Logan & Cove Differ From Douglas Mattress?

Mattress Construction

The fundamental difference lies in construction philosophy. Douglas embraces pure foam mattress construction with three carefully calibrated layers: a 2-inch gel foam comfort layer, a 2-inch Elastex transition layer, and a 6-inch high-density support base with motion-isolation support foam.

Logan & Cove takes a hybrid mattress approach with a quilted cover, 1-inch cooling gel foam, 1.5-inch Elastex transition layer, and a substantial 9-inch individually pocketed coil system. This construction provides the contouring benefits of foam while adding the responsiveness and balanced support of traditional springs.

At Fawcett, we understand the importance of quality construction—our natural latex mattresses similarly combine premium materials for optimal support and comfort.

Motion Transfer and Edge Support

Douglas excels at motion isolation with less motion transfer than the average mattress. Thanks to its all-foam design, the mattress minimizes motion transfer, allowing partners with differing sleep patterns to sleep undisturbed.

Logan & Cove's hybrid design transmits more motion than its rating (6.4/10) suggests, but delivers exceptional edge support at 9.5/10. The coil system maintains structural integrity even when you sit on the mattress edge, providing more usable sleeping surface.

Firmness

Both mattresses fall within the medium-firm range, but feel different. Douglas rates 6.0-6.9/10 on the firmness scale, providing controlled sinkage with minimal bounce. Logan & Cove rates average, offering a medium-firm feel that's slightly softer, with moderate bounce from its coil system.

The different constructions mean firmness feels distinct: Douglas provides gradual foam compression, while Logan & Cove offer initial softness followed by coil pushback.

Motion Isolation

This represents one of the biggest performance gaps between these mattresses. Douglas's foam construction reduces motion transfer compared to average mattresses, making partner movements virtually unnoticeable through superior motion isolation.

Logan & Cove's individually wrapped coils, despite moving independently, still transmit more motion across the surface. Light sleepers with restless partners should strongly consider Douglas's motion-isolation advantage.

Cooling Features

Both mattresses incorporate cooling technologies, but Logan & Cove leads with a 9.0/10 cooling score. Its hybrid construction creates natural airflow through the coil system, while the thin 3-inch comfort layer prevents heat retention, helping you sleep cool.

Douglas performs well in cooling tests but relies primarily on gel infused foam and moisture-wicking covers rather than structural airflow. Both should satisfy most sleepers, but hot sleepers may prefer Logan & Cove's superior ventilation for cooler sleep.

Warranty Years

Douglas provides a 20-year warranty, offering longer protection than Logan & Cove's 15-year coverage. Both warranties are non-prorated, meaning full coverage throughout the warranty period, with no depreciation.

However, warranty length matters less than understanding what's covered—both protect against manufacturing defects, sagging over 2 inches, and structural failures while excluding normal wear and damage. Our Fawcett mattresses come with a comprehensive 10-year warranty covering craftsmanship and materials.

Sleep Trial Nights

Both companies offer identical 365-night sleep trials, giving you an entire year to evaluate your mattress purchase. This extended sleep trial period far exceeds industry standards and demonstrates confidence in their products.

The trials begin 30 nights after delivery and include free pickup and full refunds. Both companies donate returned mattresses to charity rather than reselling them.

Shipping, Setup, and Customer Service

Both mattress brands provide free shipping across Canada and similar unboxing experiences. Mattresses arrive compressed in boxes and expand to full size within hours of unboxing, whether you're setting up in a guest room or master bedroom.

Logan & Cove operates from Edmonton with a customer service team available Monday-Friday 10 AM-7 PM EST and weekends 10 AM-6 PM EST. Douglas provides similar support hours with Canadian-based representatives.

Both companies typically ship in-stock items within 2-3 business days, with custom orders taking up to 15 business days for Logan & Cove. At Fawcett, we craft each custom mattress to your specifications with personal attention to detail.

Which Mattress Offers the Best Value for Your Money?

Douglas delivers exceptional value at $799 CAD for a queen, positioning itself $200 below Logan & Cove while providing excellent motion isolation and cooling. For budget-conscious buyers who prioritize partner compatibility, Douglas offers outstanding value.

Logan & Cove justifies its $999 CAD price point through hybrid construction, superior edge support, and enhanced responsiveness. The additional cost brings traditional mattress benefits—bounce and structural support — that all-foam constructions can't match.

Consider Douglas if you prioritize motion isolation and affordability. Choose Logan & Cove if you value responsive feel and edge support enough to justify the premium.

Which Mattress Should You Choose Based on Your Sleep Style?

• Side Sleepers: Both perform well for side sleepers, but lighter individuals under 130 pounds might find Logan & Cove too firm initially. Heavier side sleepers over 250 pounds should choose Logan Cove for its deeper coil support and better pressure-point relief.
• Back Sleepers: Both mattresses provide excellent support for back sleepers across different sleeping positions. Logan & Cove's coils offer more pushback for heavier individuals, while Douglas provides consistent support across a wider weight range.
• Stomach Sleepers: Logan & Cove's firmer coil system better prevents hip sinkage, which can stress the lower back. Douglas works for lighter stomach sleepers but may lack the firm mattress support needed for heavier individuals.
• Combination Sleepers: Logan & Cove's moderate bounce and faster response time make position changes easier throughout the night, regardless of sleeping position. Douglas's low bounce requires more effort to shift positions.
• Couples: If motion isolation is crucial, choose Douglas. If you need full edge support and don't mind moderate motion transfer, Logan & Cove provides a more usable sleeping surface.

Understanding your sleep style helps you choose the right mattress. Our hybrid mattress collection offers similar benefits to Logan & Cove but with natural latex for enhanced durability and breathability.

What Are the Benefits & Drawbacks of Each Mattress?

Douglas Benefits:

• Superior motion isolation for couples
• Excellent value at $799 CAD
• 20-year warranty coverage
• Designed specifically for Canadian sleepers and the climate
• Low-maintenance all-foam construction

Douglas Drawbacks:

• Limited bounce makes position changes harder
• Less edge support than hybrid designs
• May lack firmness for heavier sleepers
• All foam feel may not appeal to traditional mattress users

Logan & Cove Benefits:

• Exceptional edge support and usable surface
• Hybrid construction provides a familiar feel
• Excellent cooling through coil ventilation
• Better for combination sleepers
• Premium foam materials and construction

Logan & Cove Drawbacks:

• Higher price point at $999 CAD
• More motion transfer than foam mattresses
• Complex construction may develop issues over time
• Shorter 15-year warranty period

For those seeking the benefits of both approaches, explore our latex hybrid mattresses that combine natural materials with responsive support systems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Logan & Cove a good mattress for back pain?

Logan & Cove can help with back pain through its zoned coil system and pressure-relieving foam layers. The hybrid construction provides targeted support for different body areas while maintaining spinal alignment and pressure relief, promoting your best sleep possible. Also, you can pair it with premium mattress protectors and a breathable mattress cover to extend durability and comfort. However, mattress selection for back pain is highly individual, so, consider consulting with a healthcare provider.

Are Logan & Cove mattresses good?

Logan & Cove mattresses earn consistently positive reviews, with a 4.7/5-star rating across over 5,000 customer reviews. Independent testing confirms good performance in cooling, pressure relief, and edge support. The brand has received recognition as Canada's Best Luxury Mattress and Best Hybrid Mattress for 2025.

Which Douglas mattress is best?

Douglas currently offers one mattress model: the Douglas Original. This all-foam construction targets the broadest range of sleepers with its medium firm mattress feel and excellent motion isolation. The company focuses on perfecting this single design rather than offering multiple models.

How does the Douglas mattress compare to others?

Douglas stands out for exceptional motion isolation and a strong value proposition at $799 CAD. It performs particularly well against other all-foam mattresses in cooling and off-gassing tests. The 20-year warranty and 365-night trial provide additional value compared to competitors.

Conclusion

Both Douglas and Logan & Cove represent excellent choices within the Canadian mattress market, each excelling in different performance areas. Douglas provides superior motion isolation and value for couples and hot sleepers, while Logan & Cove delivers hybrid construction benefits, including edge support and responsiveness for combination sleepers, helping ensure restful sleep night after night.

Your decision should align with your specific sleep priorities and budget. Consider Douglas for exceptional motion isolation at an accessible price, or choose Logan & Cove for a traditional mattress feel with modern convenience. Both companies back their products with industry-leading 365-night trials, allowing you to experience the difference risk-free, whether you’re upgrading from an old mattress or furnishing a new home.

For those seeking natural, sustainable alternatives crafted on Vancouver Island, explore our mattress collection made with 100% natural Talalay latex and organic materials. Our 100-night comfort exchange gives you the flexibility to find the ideal mattress feel that matches your unique comfort preferences.

Citations:
[1] https://naplab.com/mattress-reviews/logan-and-cove-choice-review/
[2] https://www.mattress-reviews.com/mattress-reviews/douglas-mattress-review/
[3] https://www.mattress-reviews.com/mattress-comparisons/douglas-vs-logan-and-cove-mattress-review/
[4] https://naplab.com/mattress-reviews/douglas-mattress-review/
[5] https://www.sleepfoundation.org/mattress-reviews/douglas-mattress-review